Jump to content

UPDATED: Rate the first songs released from Madame X in order


Recommended Posts

20 hours ago, Jim34 said:

Medellin - 9

I rise - 7

Crave  - 4

It took me a while to get Into Crave. After hearing it more than ten times it got me hooked. Now Crave - 8

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rise > Crave > Medellin

I hate her vocals on the "1, 2, 1, 2, 3" parts on the song they sound so rough. Maluma is also unnecessary. I love the shorted version without these parts though.

Rise is just perfect and Crave is nice, but I want to think the best is yet to come.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Medellin 10

Crave 10

I Rise 8

 

Medellin and Crave are equally strong songs though totally different and both have immense replay value - I never get tired to listen to them, they only get better with each listen. I Rise pales a little in comparison.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 - Crave : I'm completely in love with this song but most of all with her voice and the way she sings... Such humanity and fragility


2 - Medellin : A very good song, very cleverly produced and built... I love the bridge and the chorus but the voice effects blocks me from being moved by the verses even though the lyrics are beautiful

 

3- I Rise : I think this song will make more sense once hearing the full album... If it was sang with the same intentions as Crave I would probably be addicted

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Medellin 9/10 --> It's so fresh, catchy and original, a perfect combination of the best Madonna, Mirwais style and Maluma's charm. For me it's already a classic.

Crave 8'5/10 --> Really beautiful, a delicate and touching ballad. Sometimes less is more. Swae Lee is one of the best featurings she's ever had.

I Rise 6'5/10 --> It's a good song but not my type. I like the multi-layered chorus and overall good production. It's a fine way to end the album.

Edited by JohnnyUtah
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Medellin 11/10 It is that damn good.  I love every single thing about this song.  This is an instant classic.  So complex and delicious.  An absolute delight.

Crave 9.5/10. The bridge gives me serious Justify My Love vibes.  Swae Lee is great on it and the two blend fantastically.  I love the mumble rap.  This song is exactly what a featured artist selection should be.  Perfection.  Would get a 10 if the lyrics were just a bit more clear.  It is just a little hard to understand what she is singing, here and there.  Still love this song.  

I Rise. 9/10.  Would get a 10 if it was longer.  It is a bit too short to be anthemic.  I also wish that she had included additional "speeches" to extend the message to other issues.  However, I love the lyrics and the autotune actually works for me.  Just wish that it was longer.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Medellin 11/10 It is that damn good.  I love every single thing about this song.  This is an instant classic.  So complex and delicious.  An absolute delight.

Crave 9.5/10. The bridge gives me serious Justify My Love vibes.  Swae Lee is great on it and the two blend fantastically.  I love the mumble rap.  This song is exactly what a featured artist selection should be.  Perfection.  Would get a 10 if the lyrics were just a bit more clear.  It is just a little hard to understand what she is singing, here and there.  Still love this song.  

I Rise. 9/10.  Would get a 10 if it was longer.  It is a bit too short to be anthemic.  I also wish that she had included additional "speeches" to extend the message to other issues.  However, I love the lyrics and the autotune actually works for me.  Just wish that it was longer.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Medellin_____6/10 (Video 10/10) that song gives me feeling like Maluma part is a paste copy on some cool Madonna solo demo song

I rise______5/10, 100% Madonna song, multi-layer vocal kills the vibe of the song, production try to imitates Mirwais past work and fails 

Crave_____8/10, best featuring in any Madonna collaboration, don't like that repeating;  rush, russssh, rushh, ...komm, komg, kong, love, luv, luuvvv!!!???? and if producers find better vocal ideas for that part the song will, for me be 10/10

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Amelia aka Neutrocks

I must admit, all three didn't grab me right off.  Most definitely, they are growers, and I think "Crave" is so damn infectious.  I listen to that one the most of the three.  But compared to her catalog, these don't hold a candle to most of her iconic songs:

I Rise: 7/10  Interestingly enough, this song I like right off than the other two, but I listen to this the less.

Medellin: 8/10  It took a few listens before I got into this one, but it's great.  I think Maluma completes this song very much.  His parts grabbed me more than Madonna's. 

Crave: 9/10  I agree this is "pop perfection".  I love everything about this song.  Again, Swae Lee makes this song pop just as Madonna. 

I have a feeling these songs aren't even the best off the album.  But they are so darn fun to listen to, especially "Medellin" and "Crave". 

Edited by Amelia aka Neutrocks
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Medellin 9/10 Song and Video

I Rise   7/10 Song

Crave 9/10 Song, with huge Streaming potential

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Medellín - i absolutely adore this song. I have listened to it hundreds of times already and now have the remixes on repeat also

Crave - beautiful song - gorgeous

I Rise - good song, great last minute

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/10/2019 at 2:42 AM, rekha said:

1. Crave 10/10 Love her voice and the melody

2. Medellin 9/10 Something unexpected and new from her. The video is also amazing!

3. I Rise 8/10 I love the chorus. 

Extremely happy with all 3 releases thus far❤️❤️👍👍㊗️㊗️🎉🎉

this would be my vote exactly!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

58 minutes ago, tuckeye said:

this would be my vote exactly!

Great minds... 😝😝

Link to comment
Share on other sites

# 1 - Medellin (8/10)

# 2 - Crave (7/10)

# 3 - I Rise (6/10)

Like them all, much better than Living For Love or Bitch I`m Madonna...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Medellín (10/10) - Atypical song and song structure and the structure/production are incredible...such a grower.

2. Crave (9/10) - Love the singing, mellowness and Swae Lee is also a genius (Swaecation is excellent)

3. I Rise (8/10) - The more I've listened the more I like it, but feels more like an album track to me, still great and I look forward to hearing it in the context of the full album. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...