Mooncrown11 Posted September 28, 2014 Posted September 28, 2014 What are your 50 most treasured Madonna songs at the moment and how would you rank them? How does your list compare to your fellow members' lists? Which of your favorites will make the list and which will miss the cut? What song will be voted the ultimate # 1 ? What exactly is going on with Madonna's new album and when will it be released? Some but not all of these questions will soon be answered once the votes are cast and I calculate the results and count them down for your viewing pleasure! So here's how it will work...Everyone who would like to participate will post their top 50 songs in order and I will assign points to each song depending on where it is ranked on each list. There will be 2 points awarded to a #50 ranked song, 4 points for a #49 song and so on up to a 100 points awarded to each song ranked as #1. For example, if someone ranks Holiday as #50 and another person ranks it #1, it would have a total of 102 points. So the order you rank the songs is just as important as the songs you choose. Any Madonna song is eligible including album tracks, demos , and b-sides. While I encourage you to list a certain version of a song that you prefer, I will count all votes toward the song itself instead of separating them into different buckets by version . When everyone has had a chance to vote, I will calculate the results and count them down 10 at a time along with some interesting statistics about the votes Sound good?I know this is a huge undertaking and may require a bit of soul searching to come up with your definitive list so I plan to leave the voting open for a while to give all who want to vote a chance to do so. If it is possible also, would one of the admins be so kind as to pin the thread so it stays visible on the 1st page? I know it may not be easy and your list may change next month or even tomorrow, but just choose the 50 songs that are speaking to you the most at the moment and let everyone know what they are. Don't be afraid to be honest-even if it is not the popular opinion. This is a judgement-free topic (at least I hope it will be) So.. What are you gonna do? Get voting of course!! Thanks in advance for indulging me and have fun with this
Mooncrown11 Posted September 28, 2014 Author Posted September 28, 2014 Mooncrown, do we PM our lists to you ? You can PM me if you want to or just post the list in the thread. I'm good either way. Thanks Jan!
Guest ditaluver Posted September 28, 2014 Posted September 28, 2014 I will really have to think about this
Mooncrown11 Posted September 28, 2014 Author Posted September 28, 2014 I will really have to think about this Take your time ditaluver-no rush!
MerGirl Posted September 28, 2014 Posted September 28, 2014 This isn't going to be easy, lol. I'm so bad at making lists like these.
Msig Posted September 29, 2014 Posted September 29, 2014 I've made such lists before, in the AbsMad forum Difficult as hell, and I always end up having second thoughts about having placed certain songs in certain positions, but I WILL do it this time around, too
Msig Posted September 29, 2014 Posted September 29, 2014 1. Like a Prayer 2. Express Yourself 3. Celebration 4. Vogue 5. Give Me All Your Luvin' 6. I'm Addicted 7. Turn Up the Radio 8. Love Spent 9. Girl Gone Wild 10. Hung Up 11. Music 12. Hollywood 13. Give It 2 Me 14. Into the Groove 15. Gang Bang 16. Ray of Light 17. Revolver 18. La Isla Bonita 19. Open Your Heart 20. Papa Don't Preach 21. I Don't Give A 22. She's Not Me 23. Nobody Knows Me 24. Like a Virgin 25. 4 Minutes 26. Candy Shop 27. Human Nature 28. Falling Free 29. Devil Wouldn't Recognize You 30. Masterpiece 31. Lucky Star 32. Justify My Love 33. Erotica 34. I'm a Sinner 35. Frozen 36. Nothing Fails 37. Impressive Instant 38. I'm Going Bananas 39. Drowned World/Substitute for Love 40. Burning Up 41. Beat Goes On 42. Don't Tell Me 43. Secret 44. Forbidden Love (2005) 45. Paradise (Not for Me) 46. Beautiful Stranger 47. Die Another Day 48. Easy Ride 49. Jump 50. Broken
Guest CzarnaWisnia Posted September 29, 2014 Posted September 29, 2014 here's mine: 1. Frozen 2. Like a Prayer 3. The Power of Goodbye 4. Paradise 5. Intervention 6. Bedtime Story 7. Live To Tell 8. Holiday 9. Easy Ride 10. Love Tried To Welcome Me 11. La Isla Bonita 12. Sanctuary 13. Falling Free 14. Mother and Father 15. Impressive Instant 16. Music 17. Masterpiece 18. X-Static Process 19. Has To Be 20. I'll Remember 21. Papa Don't Preach 22. Inside of Me 23. Secret 24. Die Another Day 25. I Want You 26. Mer Girl 27. Time Stood Still 28. Something to Remember 29. Deeper and Deeper 30. Human Nature 31. Gone 32. Ray of Light 33. Drowned World 34. Isaac 35. Vogue 36. It's so Cool (2002) 37. Secret Garden 38. Borderline 39. Fighting Spirit 40. Corazon 41. Get Together 42. Forbidden Love (Bedtime) 43. Love Spent 44. Promise To Try 45. Hung Up 46. Physical Attraction 47. You'll See 48. Skin 49. I Deserve It 50. Voices
Msig Posted September 29, 2014 Posted September 29, 2014 here's mine OMG! How could I have left out "Easy Ride" from my top 50!?
Mooncrown11 Posted September 29, 2014 Author Posted September 29, 2014 I've made such lists before, in the AbsMad forum Difficult as hell, and I always end up having second thoughts about having placed certain songs in certain positions, but I WILL do it this time around, too Nice to see another fellow former AbsMadder here Thanks for continuing to play along!
Mooncrown11 Posted September 29, 2014 Author Posted September 29, 2014 OMG! How could I have left out "Easy Ride" from my top 50!? You can always edit if you need to . I'll probably not add up the votes until the end and I will give warning first.
Sloane Posted September 30, 2014 Posted September 30, 2014 50! Too hard and for what? No one's gonna read it anyway I like all of 'em except Cherish, Borderline, TUTR and not really into Holiday. There. That was easier.
JimmyJimmy Posted September 30, 2014 Posted September 30, 2014 50! Too hard and for what? No one's gonna read it anyway I like all of 'em except Cherish, Borderline, TUTR and not really into Holiday. There. That was easier. Omg same! I'm not really into any of those 4 as well!
jacket Posted September 30, 2014 Posted September 30, 2014 This is how i feel as of this moment. 1. Beautiful Stranger 2. Burning Up 3. Don't Tell Me 4. Waiting 5. Human Nature 6. Cherish 7. Erotica 8. What It Feels Like For A Girl (album version) 9. Get Together 10. Secret 11. Crazy For You 12. Paradise 13. Hollywood (Jacques Lu Cont's Thin White Duke Mix) 14. Drowned World (Substitute for Love) 15. Let Down Your Guard 16. Sanctuary 17. Take A Bow 18. Ray of Light 19. Borderline 20. Like A Prayer 21. Shanti (Ashtangi) 22. To Have And Not To Hold 23. Secret Garden 24. La Isla Bonita 25. Nothing Really Matters 26. Rain 27. Justify My Love 28. Lucky Star 29. Power Of Goodbye 30. Frozen 31. Music 32. Holiday 33. Open Your Heart 34. This Used To Be My Playground 35. Bad Girl 36. Let It Will Be (Paper Faces Mix) 37. You'll See 38. Into The Groove 39. Material Girl 40. Skin 41. Bedtime Story 42. I'll Remember 43. Like A Virgin 44. Hung Up 45. Candy Perfume Girl 46. Vogue 47. Give It 2 Me 48. Express Yourself 49. Jump 50. Fever
runa Posted September 30, 2014 Posted September 30, 2014 I do my have my list but I must put it in order...!!! It will be hard...
Titty Posted September 30, 2014 Posted September 30, 2014 Here is mine, with the 80s and 90s ruling 1. Justify My Love 2. Like A Prayer 3. Erotica 4. Vogue 5. Lucky Star 6. Angel 7. Papa Don't Preach 8. Get Together 9. Express Yourself 10. Into The Groove 11. Borderline 12. Ray Of Light 13. Open Your Heart 14. Frozen 15. Secret Garden 16. Physical Attraction 17. Deeper & Deeper 18. Cherish 19. Drowned World 20. Holiday 21. Live To Tell 22. Hung Up 23. Everybody 24. Supernatural 25. Material Girl 26. Music 27. Who's That Girl 28. Give It 2 Me 29. I'm Addicted 30. Can't Stop 31. Bedtime Story 32. Spotlight 33. Secret 34. Where Life Begins 35. Like A Virgin 36. What It Feels Like For A Girl 37. Till Death Do Us Part 38. Candy Shop 39. Rescue Me 40. Dress You Up 41. Love Song 42. Inside Of Me 43. Jump 44. Sanctuary 45. Think Of Me 46. Beautiful Stranger 47. Crazy For You 48. Bye Bye Baby 49. True Blue 50. Waiting
madgemusic85 Posted September 30, 2014 Posted September 30, 2014 50. Supernatural 49. Spotlight 48. Love Song with Prince 47. Stay (demo) 46. Bedtime Stories 45. Shoo bee doo 44. Fever 43. Love makes the world go round 42. Causing A Commotion 41. Ain't No Big Deal 40. Lucky Star 39. Cherish 38. Don't Cry For Me Argentina 37. Frozen 36. You'll See 35. Where's The Party 34. Bad Girl 33. The Power Of Goodbye 32. Don't Tell Me 31. Material Girl 30. Jump 29. La Isla Bonita 28. Give It To Me 27. Die Another Day 26. What it feels like for a girl 25. Angel 24. Express Yourself 23. Candy Shop 22. Vogue 21. Crazy For You 20. Physical Attraction 19. Keep It Together 18. Deeper and Deeper 17. Who's That Girl 16. Like A Virgin 15. Hung Up 14. Ray of Light 13. Music 12. Holiday 11. Nobody's Perfect 10. Erotica 9. Live To Tell 8. Justify My Love 7. This Used To Be My Childhood Playground 6. Open Your Heart 5. Dress You Up 4. Papa Don't Preach 3. Borderline 2. Into The Groove 1. Like A Prayer
Guest Borderline Posted September 30, 2014 Posted September 30, 2014 Think before I do my list, I'm going to do a listening marathon... <plays Lucky Star...>
Titty Posted September 30, 2014 Posted September 30, 2014 Madgemusic 85, our lists are relatively similar. :-)
madgemusic85 Posted September 30, 2014 Posted September 30, 2014 Madgemusic 85, our lists are relatively similar. :-) Coool!
mnino Posted September 30, 2014 Posted September 30, 2014 1 Vogue 2 Like A Prayer 3 Drowned World (Substitute for Love) 4 Waiting 5 Don't Tell Me 6 Open Your Heart 7 Into The Groove 8 Secret 9 Physical Attraction 10 Express Yourself 11 Take a Bow 12 Ray of Light 13 Music 14 Live to Tell 15 Frozen 16 Love Spent 17 Swim 18 Lucky Star 19 Spotlight 20 More 21 Candy Shop 22 Masterpiece 23 Papa Don't Preach 24 Holiday 25 You Must Love Me 26 Promise To Try 27 True Blue 28 Beautiful Stranger 29 Cherish 30 Isaac 31 Candy Perfume Girl 32 He's a Man 33 This Used To Be My Playground 34 Where's The Party 35 Get Together 36 Turn Up The Radio 37 Back in Business 38 Erotica 39 Falling Free 40 Nobody Knows Me 41 Borderline 42 Beat Goes On 43 Paradise (Not For Me) 44 Keep It Together 45 Sanctuary 46 I Want You 47 Die Another Day 48 4 Minutes 49 I'd Rather Be Your Lover 50 Rescue Me
motherandfather03 Posted September 30, 2014 Posted September 30, 2014 like a prayer hung up celebration promise to try x static process girl gone wild dear jessie push live to tell I'll remember till death do us part the power of goodbye sky fits heaven forbidden love 05 sorry give it 2 me how high secret vogue drowned world frozen rain like it or not crazy for you ray of light I'm a sinner survival express yourself american pie theif of hearts voices paradise let it will be 4 minutes nothing fails get together turn up the radio nobody's perfect open your heart luck star confessions don't tell me papa don't preach die another day like a virgin confession tour you must love me la isla bonita confessions music holiday into the groove material girl hey. here you go!!
Guest Rachelle of London Posted September 30, 2014 Posted September 30, 2014 Mooncrown this is torture. I need a few days hagaha
motherandfather03 Posted September 30, 2014 Posted September 30, 2014 sorry, it came distorted. Here is my list from 1-50 1. like a prayer 2. hung up 3. celebration 4. promise to try 5. x-static process 6. girl gone wild 7. dear jessie 8. push 9. i'll remember 10. live to tell 11. till death do us part 12. forbidden love 05 13. sky fits heaven 14. sorry 15. the power of goodbye 16. give it 2 me 17. how high 18. secret 19. vogue 20. drowned world 21. frozen 22. rain 23. crazy for you 24. how high 25. like it or not 26. i'm a sinner 27. survival 28. american pie 29. theif of hearts 30. express yourself 31. voices 32. paradise not for me 33. nothing fails 34. 4. minutes 35. let it will be 36. get together 37. lucky star (confessions tour) 38. turn up the radio 39. open your heart 40. nobody's perfect 41. don't tell me 42. papa don't preach 43. like a virgin (confessions tour) 44. you must love me 45. die another day 46. la isla bonita (confessions tour) 47. into the groove 48. material girl 49. holiday 50. music please delete my previous post. thanks!!
Guest CJM Posted October 1, 2014 Posted October 1, 2014 Omg I'm so keen to do this! I love making lists. Picking the songs should be easy enough but puting them in order oh dear lord. So much fun but so hard!
Mooncrown11 Posted October 1, 2014 Author Posted October 1, 2014 Mooncrown this is torture. I need a few days hagaha I know I'm sorry! Just think how good you'll feel when it's done Take your time
Recommended Posts