rocknrolla
-
Posts
435 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Posts posted by rocknrolla
-
-
Using the remix in tbe video certainly didn't help, tho I liked it.
-
The article states half the stations are playing the Madonna only version, because the listeners don't know who swae is. Like they can't learn!
Another person says that even for AC it is too much of a hooky rap! not a rap at all
-
I don't search I find -- I love the idea behind it, that artists are determined to continue creating, from Picasso
Extreme occident-autobiographical
Come alive and crazy, although I really like other songs with those titles, so it will be hard to top them
I WAS very intrigued by kwap, but it seems every one hates it
I am worried I won't be able to get into the foreign language songs, and there are so many of them
-
I think it does genuinely confuse some reviewers that she's still recording music at 60 when she's already so rich and successful. She must have a passion for it. Like most of her children even play instruments and she says she has a very musical household. I think some people think she just walks into a studio every four years or so throws down some vocals and doesn't have much involvement in the process
-
This bothers me, it may be my favorite duet of hers
-
That is what is stupid, 99 percent of the time I listen to her music on Spotify because I like her songs, I don't think about her controversies or watch music videos
-
I think it is a great duet, I hate that some stations are playing the Madonna only version
-
Metacritic is used in alot of Stan wars it seems to me. Beyonce fans in particular, since she scores so high.
Taylor's scores are just average, and Gaga has aren't so good either. She almost had an 80 with the star is born soundtrack
-
ME sucks, but isn't really a whole lot different than Taylor's other songs, because none of them were really all that good to begin with.
-
32 minutes ago, yououghttavogue said:
One song doesnt ruin an album- pitchfork knows that. Theyll totally blast her for Killers, but thats not the end of the world. Their critique of Rebel Heart was that it was mishmashed and done-before. Madame X sounds like it has a thoughtful vibe and is woven more carefully than rebel heart. So i dont think a 5.5 rating is written in stone. Really. If I had to predict, it will be high sixes, maybe 6.6 or 6.7. Which is a great score.
That would be a great score -- for Pitchfork, but for overall ratings, it is not
-
Exotic, breezy mood sounds completely opposite from bleak
-
That description sounds great, though!
-
Wouldn't it be something if she performed some of her gayest songs? Erotica, where life begins, why's it so hard, fobidden love?
-
That's great that it is getting any airplay at all
-
At least Prides are probably bigger than ever now, but a small part of me is slighty disappointed she is doing Prides now like she is Debbie Gibson or Cyndi Lauper or something, I know that sounds awful
-
That does sound a little better, but most people would see three out of five and think meh. Strong reviews would really help. Sometimes I will run across a good review of an artist I had not paid attention to in awhile and it motivates me to check out their new work.
-
5 minutes ago, headonfire said:
A 2 or a 1 star score is bad, not a 3 star.
These were RS scores on her previous albums, as shared by @Shaun earlier in the thread.
Debut: no star rating
LAV: 3.5
TB: no star rating
LAP: 3.5
E: 4
BS: 3.5
ROL: 4
Music: 4
AL: 3
Confessions: 3.5
HC: 4
MDNA: 3.5
RH: 3.5
MX: 3
So no, not her worst score ever from RS. They also gave AL a 3 star, and it's a brilliant work of art. So to be honest, after reading their basic review which barely talks about the music, I couldn't care less what score RS gives.
A 3 star review is not good, it is a score of 60 out of 100.
-
I know they've reviewed her first album and True Blue. I think her first was 3-3.5 stars.
4 minutes ago, Amelia said:Which makes no sense at all. You'd think people would respect a person (especially a woman) who keeps taking punches and continues to be at the top of her game. We just live in a society where people love to knock people down and since she doesn't stop, people keep knocking. I'm just happy she doesn't care!
She's the Hilary Clinton, people seem to hate her for really no reason at all
-
11 hours ago, acko said:
I'm confused... Why the negativity?
A three star review is not good, especially from Rolling Stone. Her worst score ever.
-
No one is talking about quavo ruining the performance
-
Speaking of ghost town, I thought one of her all time worst performances was where she was just sitting on a stool, had screens playing behind her and she still sounded awful. Maybe Ellen?
At least eurovision had the excuse of having stairs and choreography!
-
On 5/21/2019 at 4:22 PM, Miphiwart said:
I really like this one
This is mine too. I hope the loses the eyepatch soon
-
I do hate the fact that she helped extend the careers of pink, Gaga, etc when they should've been over by now
-
The problem with like a prayer live is that the gospel choir already carries the song, so when she can't even sing her part, it looks very bad.
Overall, though, I liked the performance, I like the visuals, the spoken part in the middle, and I really like Future, but it seems divisive.
MADAME X: official reviews are in: MADAME X is a hit with the critics!
in ARCHIVE - The MADAME X Forum
Posted
I had a feeling the reviews would be positive. I've really liked the released tracks, and it sounds like they aren't even the highlights