Jump to content

nevermind

Advanced Members
  • Posts

    83
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by nevermind

  1. Yeah it's a nonsense list. Billboard themselves compiled a ranking of the most successful Hot 100 artists of all time (with Madonna at #2 behind The Beatles); this is just a poor knock-off version designed to be low-hanging clickbait for internet stans.

    This only takes into account Top 10 hits, and fails to factor in the length of stay within the Top 10. So a song that peaked at say #4 but lasted 10 weeks within the Top 10 would receive less points than a song that spent one week at #2, when manifestly the former is the bigger hit. Billboard's methodology for its own list recognised Top 40 hits (and remember reaching the Top 40 has always been the standard metric for a "hit") and incorporated longevity. Time's list is just a redundant version of that.

  2. Agreed. I've also always thought there's a really religious, spiritual quality to the song - similar to Like A Prayer.

    It's interesting that she references rain in several of her most poetic songs - here obviously, but also in Secret Garden (if I wait for the rain to kiss me and undress me..), Sanctuary (who needs the sun when the rain's so full of life) and Mer Girl (I ran to the sky, out to the lake, into the rain that matted my hair, and soaked my shoes and skin... I tasted the rain, I tasted my tears).

    Two might be a coincidence, but four (there could even be more?) is a pattern. I think rain for M is absolutely a symbol of life and cum fertility and motherhood and by consequence her Mother.

    In Rain she's waiting on that mountain top endlessly for the storm to pass and in Mer Girl she's running to the lake and up to the hill and she's looking there still and she's always, forever haunted by her mother's spirit.

  3. Rain despite its blatant extended cum metaphor could also be about her mother right? I mean:

    "When you looked into my eyes, and you said goodbye could you see my tears?"

    "By sheer voice of will (I feel like a magical child), I will raise you from the ground"

    Rain works just as well as a metaphor for the elemental force of love coming down from the heavens above (which she already referenced in D&D). It always sounded to me like it was a song about a deceased lover, but with M it wouldn't surprise me if it was another codified paean to her mother, like Inside of Me.

    I never feel like I can over-analyse Erotica, she's operating on so many levels on this album - from the song titles down.

  4. M, no matter how many meanings you give to it, sounds less inspired than MDNA which was brilliant.

    Yeah MDNA was an incredible title - right up there with the likes of The Immaculate Collection as titles go. Shame it's lack of success and quality compared to the rest of her albums has left it with a poor reputation. If she'd had called Confessions MDNA (which would have totally fit - it's far more of a ecstasy fuelled rave up than a confessional work) it would have been I-C-O-N-I-C.

  5. I agree . During the time of Hung Up US Radio was very hip hip driven. I remembered reading an article where her then label WB said they were having a hard time getting her played on US radio because COTDF was a dance record.

    This is the quote :

    Warner Bros. was aware that the songs on "Confessions" could present challenges at mainstream top 40 radio, acknowledges Tom Biery, senior VP of promotions at Warner Bros. "Top 40 radio is so hip-hop-driven," he says. "We were coming in with a global pop star who made a dance record."

    Yeah this is all correct, the age/radio backlash think is totally overstated when it comes to "Hung Up" and COADF. Remember how Gwen's "What You Waiting For?" bombed in the same year before she followed it with the Eve featuring "Rich Girl" and Neptunes' "Holloback Girl" - dance music had no chance of going anywhere on US radio in 2002-2005.

    And it wasn't just that "Hung Up" was dance, it was straight up disco - the most loathed and feared of all dance subgenres in the US. Even when "EDM" exploded in the US in the late 00s the music that dominated the charts has been mostly synth driven brostep - disco by and large is considered too gay for America.

×
×
  • Create New...