Jump to content

Mattress

Supreme Elitists
  • Posts

    8,126
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Mattress

  1. Assuming that the GH will be two discs, this would be my track listing:

    Disc 1:

    Holiday

    Borderline

    Lucky Star

    Like a Virgin

    Material Girl

    Crazy for You

    Into the Groove

    Dress You Up

    Live to Tell

    Papa Don't Preach

    True Blue

    Open Your Heart

    La Isla Bonita

    Who's That Girl

    Causing a Commotion

    Like a Prayer

    Express Yourself

    Cherish

    Disc 2:

    Vogue

    Justify My Love

    This Used to Be My Playground

    Erotica

    Deeper and Deeper

    I'll Remember

    Secret

    Take a Bow

    Frozen

    Ray of Light

    Beautiful Stranger

    Music

    Don't Tell Me

    Die Another Day

    Hung Up

    4 Minutes

    Celebrate

    Revolver

    That would be 18 tracks on each disc. And if single edits were used, they should fit on two 80-minute discs (assuming about 4 minutes per song for the two new tracks).

    With one addition, that's the tracklisting I've stuck to since the mention of new recordings being included. The only thing that differs is mine also includes "Angel" on disc one. It fills the CD just past 79 minutes and makes it so that her entire, legendary run of consecutive top 5 US hits --"Lucky Star" to "Cherish"!-- are included. Disc two (once the new songs are added) would land somewhere in the 78-80 minute range.

    So, to me, the perfect tracklisting would be:

    CD1

    Holiday

    Borderline

    Lucky Star

    Like A Virgin

    Material Girl

    Crazy For You

    Angel

    Into The Groove

    Dress You Up

    Live To Tell

    Papa Don't Preach

    True Blue

    Open Your Heart

    La Isla Bonita

    Who's That Girl

    Causing A Commotion

    Like A Prayer

    Express Yourself

    Cherish

    CD2

    Vogue

    Justify My Love

    This Used To Be My Playground

    Erotica

    Deeper And Deeper

    I'll Remember

    Secret

    Take A Bow

    Frozen

    Ray Of Light

    Beautiful Stranger

    Music

    Don't Tell Me

    Die Another Day

    Hung Up

    4 Minutes

    Celebrate

    Revolver

  2. Billboard.com:

    BIRTH OF 'AUTO-TUNE': Jay-Z enters the Billboard Hot 100 at No. 24 with "D.O.A. (Death of Auto-Tune)." The track previews "The Blueprint 3," due Sept. 11.

    The song marks Jay-Z's 55th Hot 100 appearance, breaking him out of a tie with Madonna.

    Here is a look at the acts with 50 or more chart entries dating to the Hot 100's Aug. 4, 1958, inception:

    108, Elvis Presley

    91, James Brown

    74, Ray Charles

    73, Aretha Franklin

    71, The Beatles

    67, Elton John

    63, Stevie Wonder

    57, The Rolling Stones

    56, Marvin Gaye

    56, Frankie Valli

    56, Dionne Warwick

    55, The Beach Boys

    55, Jay-Z

    54, Madonna

    53, Neil Diamond

    53, Connie Francis

    53, The Temptations

    53, Jackie Wilson

    51, Rod Stewart

    So... Jay-Z counts as having had 55 Hot 100 entries, a large portion of which are little more than two second shout-outs on the intros of other artists singles, yet someone like, say, Michael Jackson can't count all of those Jackson 5 singles on which he sang lead toward his total?

    More Billboard bullshit.

  3. I still think *new* songs should remain on their original compilation.

    Inclusive of JML & RM will kill her best selling GH TIC.

    :confused: They were hits. This is a collection of hits. From an album, from a soundtrack, from a compilation... a hit is a hit is a hit.

    Why would it matter that they originated on a compilation? The inclusion of the fifteen classics from "Holiday" to "Vogue" on this new compilation would risk killing sales of The Immaculate Collection before "Justify My Love" alone would. The forthcoming release is likely meant to be the dominant, definitive Madonna compilation. "Killing" The Immaculate Collection thereby falls under the objective.

  4. The video is great, but on record Madonna's lead vocal should probably have been rerecorded. This wasn't a case of a raw, emotional vocal performance that couldn't be recaptured in subsequent takes (see: "Live To Tell"). It sounds like she has a bit of a head cold and much of the phrasing is whiny.

    "Bad Girl" holds the distinction of being my mom's favorite Madonna song.

  5. "Deeper And Deeper" is among my top 10 favorite Madonna songs.

    Picture this. Italy (okay, not Italy)... October 20, 1992. An eleven year old boy who did not yet have his own compact disc player (but who had been pining after one and knew it was only a matter of time) convinces his parents to buy the CD pressing of Madonna's new album Erotica to play <i>occasionally</i> on theirs. He sits down and listens to the album for the first time whilst dubbing a cassette copy for repeat listens on his own primitive stereo equipment. Suddenly, the "Vogue" ending of "Deeper And Deeper" kicks in and --all excited-like-- he mindlessly lunges toward the stereo and rewinds, fucking up his cassette recording.

    That little boy was me, and that little boy had to listen to a glitched cassette dub of his favorite song from the new album for the better part of a week before he had the opportunity to re-record it, hands restrained. And Santa brought him a CD player two months later. <i>Thank you babyjesus.</i>

    deeperremix.png

    <b>Deeper And Deeper</b> [David's Radio Edit] | download

    This is the promo only radio remix by David Morales which was the dominant radio version where I lived. This concise version features fuller instrumentation than the 12" length David's Klub Mix version (though, oddly, some synth string fills are missing during the middle break.) I like this version as much as (if not slightly more than) the original album version arrangement. The more prominent vocal harmonies sound lovely.

    <i>That's why!...</i>

  6. So, what is this song really about? Infatuation? Love? Sexuality? I get the whole idea of discovering some sort of libido but the whole "daddy couldn't be all wrong" part throws me off.

    It's always seemed straightforward to me. Sung from the perspective of a person who has either never been in love or who has had a few bad relationships, she was cynical about love and the generic idea of it. As a result she "hid" the feeling.

    The verses are cliche' things that her parents said that she lost faith in/didn't believe/didn't understand until she found someone who really loved her...someone who she likely avoided or alienated initially. So, it's her understanding the positive musings her parents instilled in her with regard to love because she's in a relationship that allows her to feel and express those things and she's using their words as a sort of validation/means to override her cynicism.

    The bridge explains the entire song: "Someone said that romance was dead, and I believed instead of remembering what my mama told me, let my father mold me, then you try to hold me...you remind me what they said. This feeling inside, I can't explain, but my love is alive and I'm never gonna hide it again."

  7. Okay. I think I've worked it out so that the only missing MADONNA! UK singles --those which were also released in the US and which sold over 100,000-- would be "Hanky Panky," "Rescue Me," "Rain," "The Power Of Good-bye," "Nothing Really Matters" and "Give It 2 Me". Taking time restraints into consideration, I think we can just about all live with that.

    Breaking down the UK sales list based on my previously posted track listing....

    FIRST TIER: The 14 strongest sellers in the UK; sold between 400,000 and 900,000

    843,561 Into The Groove

    768,129 Like A Virgin

    752,968 Holiday

    662,481 Crazy For You

    629,386 Papa Don't Preach

    534,728 True Blue

    517,036 Hung Up

    513,992 Beautiful Stranger

    513,231 Like A Prayer

    508,296 Frozen

    484,308 Vogue

    430,000 4 Minutes

    421,760 La Isla Bonita

    400,531 Music

    All of these made the track listing.

    SECOND TIER: 5 additional singles respectfully sold between 300,000 and 400,000

    389,999 Material Girl

    380,937 American Pie

    376,498 Who's That Girl

    338,494 Don't Cry For Me Argentina

    302,432 You'll See

    Of these, only the two aforementioned covers are (purposely) omitted from my previous track listing. Thus far, of Madonna's own original hits, the 17 biggest UK sellers are already included.

    THIRD TIER: 11 more singles, all sold between 200,000 and 300,000

    298,388 Borderline

    292,341 Gambler

    271,897 Live To Tell

    270,800 Erotica

    270,427 This Used To Be My Playground

    262,514 Ray Of Light

    250,769 Dear Jessie

    229,934 Causing A Commotion

    228,683 Justify My Love

    205,733 Hanky Panky

    204,970 Dress You Up

    All but three of these (two non-US releases "Gambler" and "Dear Jessie" plus "Hanky Panky") already appear on my track listing, bringing our totals to 25 of her 30 biggest UK sellers.

    FOURTH (and final) TIER: 18 additional singles that sold between 100,000 and 200,000

    198,650 Angel

    194,102 Express Yourself

    192,891 Cherish

    186,742 Open Your Heart

    179,939 Don't Tell Me

    178,963 Sorry

    175,095 The Power Of Goodbye

    167,863 Die Another Day

    148,000 Give It 2 Me

    136,854 Deeper And Deeper

    134,764 Rescue Me

    130,771 Rain

    128,137 Nothing Really Matters

    121,439 The Look Of Love

    117,957 Secret

    117,470 Lucky Star

    102,739 Take A Bow

    100,090 I'll Remember

    Of these, 11 are included on the track listing, 7 are not.

    Only 12 of 48 UK singles that sold over 100,000 copies are missing and everything is (in my opinion) well repesented from a "hits" aspect. As loomer suggested, if we found the most logical way to include "Sorry" (fourth tier seller, but an original #1 all the same) I feel my previous track listing could work for both markets.

    Ah, but how to do it...

    How about a similar list of US singles sales?

  8. In a lot of euro countries 'Gambler' was even bigger than 'Crazy For You' but Holidayperson won't believe me.

    :lol:

    I'm in the US and knew "Gambler" just as well as I did "Like A Virgin" or "Into The Groove" thanks to a certain little television network. I was surprised when I discovered it wasn't a single here.

    I always include it on my otherwise US-centric multi-disc compilations along with "Fever" and "I Want You" for their video releases.

  9. I'd go along with this exactly. Except you don't have enough space for 2 new songs, so I'd cut Die Another Day. It was much hated when it came out in certain quarters and isn't the best remembered Bond theme.

    I have a feeling that some of the 80s hits will be cut :americanlife: Angel and Commotion seem most vulnerable.

    It's a pity Oh Father and Drowned World couldn't be added to give the album more breadth and show her more thoughtful side.

    If you're wanting to do a UK version, then cut the flop I'll Remember and replace with Sorry. Fuck American Pie, # 1 or not, it was a cover :fag:

    :fag: If the two new songs run in the respectable 3:20 range (like many recent singles have) they would fit perfectly without having to drop anything from disc two.

    Definitely agree, due to the tight time restrictions, "American Pie" and "Don't Cry For Me Argentina" truly don't belong. They're covers of already famous recordings, not MADONNA! songs.

    And which flopped harder in the UK... "Take A Bow" or "I'll Remember"?

  10. That actress also made a cameo in Dennis Rodman's authorized TV movie.

    There's a clearly fabricated scene where "Dennis" and "Madonna" are breaking up in a garage (?) while paparazzi snap away. (Of course we've all seen the actual photos that this scene recreates. Not.)

    She's wearing an oriental print gown --similar to the one Madonna wore for "Take A Bow" on the AMA's but in blue-- and has what appears to be a $10 mall haircut. :rotfl:

×
×
  • Create New...