Jump to content

Macromad

Advanced Members
  • Posts

    556
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Macromad

  1. Most of the times I don't even know how the fights start. I see a bunch of completely normal opinions, a few ironic comments and then suddenly a cruel and bloody war starts...

    Back on topic. Don't forget that Orbit produced Gang Bang, Love Spent, and Falling Free the three most praised songs in the album...at least they are my favorite., It seems you're only focusing on Some Girls which is kind of lazy and Masterpiece that is too monotone.

  2. you're wasting your time :lmao: even when her collaborators have nothing but praise for her work as a songwriter/producer (like william in the interview posted in this thread - and this is only the last one from a very very long list), how much she is in control and how much she IS talented and actually is one of the few popstars that writes lyrics, melodies and actually produces her music, some "fans" keep questioning her talent and involvement during the making of her albums :lmao::lmao::lmao:

    I know some of them are pretty bad :lol: I was just making the point that she HAS actually written some songs on her own.

  3. I think I always used to give her too much credit. I always assumed it was kind of 50/50 when she listed as a co writer. When there are so many examples where she just changed a few lyrics, like with Don't Tell Me, Ray of Light, etc.

    And she has never written/produced a song by herself.

    Not being negative, just being realistic. It wouldn't bother me if she started recording music where she had little input into the process.

    Well, she may not have produced a song by herself but she wrote Lucky Star, Everybody, I Know It, Think Of Me, Burning Up, Shoo Bee Doo and Gambler by herself.

  4. I think that the general public underestimate Madonna's talent as a lyricist and producer, yes she may not be the one that makes technical work or write the lyrics out of nowhere, but she knows what she wants, how she wants the songs to sound, she probably decides where to put more drums, or strings or a synthline, she twitches the lyrics to make them more personal.

    Madonna is not Rihanna who only receives the songs and just puts her voice on them, Madonna works all day and night with her team and takes part in the decisions.

    And back on topic. Orbit's songs in MDNA are the best (except for Some Girls), the only songs from the other producers that compete with his are I Don't Give A, I'm Addicted and Beautiful Killer. MDNA could have been much better if Superstar, Some Girls and GMAYL would have been replaced with Beautiful Killer, I Fucked Up and Best Friend.

×
×
  • Create New...