Jump to content

Time to rank the Queen of Life's *studio* albums all over again


Apples388

Recommended Posts

If it is ask yourself this. If there were no Dick Tracy would it exist?—the answer is No. Let it go.

it is. nahgirluh0.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest I'llTeachYouHowTo...

how can that be? :dazed:

i rank them differently.

as far as madonna songs, it comes in at number two.

songs in general, it's number one.

i know...it's weird. :lol:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

all drama aside, unapologetically here they are:

1 LIKE A PRAYER

2 RAY OF LIGHT

3 MDNA

4 AMERICAN LIFE

5 EROTICA

6 CONFESSIONS

7 TRUE BLUE

8 MADONNA

9 BEDTIME STORIES

10 LIKE A VIRGIN

11 HARD CANDY

12 MUSIC

all love to 'music' but that's just the way it is over here right now.

ps, hayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy "I'M BREATHLESS" i will always love your yellowness, big voice, camp and dick talk =)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Xanthium

i rank them differently.

as far as madonna songs, it comes in at number two.

songs in general, it's number one.

i know...it's weird. :lol:

LOGIC FAIL :lol:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Xanthium

I respect everyone's enthusiasm, and I'm spinning the album every day (skipping GMAYL), but I'm curious to see where this album lands on people's lists one, three, 10 years from now. I feel like a lot of us are running on adrenaline right now.

Honestly for me, if I wasn't album to reorder the tracklisting to my liking and take out the filler, MDNA would've been lower than #6 on my list.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

MDNA is risky and personal and feels like a record. it's got goob-donna, sexy-donna, fun-donna, sad-donna, mdolla-donna, disco-donna, cheerleader-donna, and survivor-donna. plus her hair looks really fucking good this era. i dig the adrenaline, but i really enjoy this record.

ps. i even like the 'stupider then stupid' bday song. no, really.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

ps. i even like the 'stupider then stupid' bday song. no, really.

The world needs reasons to smile - to be carefree - and happy through art. That's what B-Day Song is—fun and joy through art.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

01. Ray of Light

02. American Life

03. MDNA

04. Madonna

05. Confessions On A Dancefloor

06. True Blue

07. Like a Prayer

08. Erotica

09. Bedtime Stories

10. Music

11. Like a Virgin

HC is not remotely good to rank any list and never cared for I'm Breathless.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Fluorine

As of right now...

1. Confessions on a Dance Floor

2. Erotica

3. Like A Prayer

4. Ray of Light

5. MDNA

6. American Life

7. Bedtime Stories

8. True Blue

9. Madonna

10. Music

11. Like A Virgin

12. Hard Candy

I don't outright hate any of her records, though. Even the ones at the bottom of my list still get played fairly often.

Edited by Fluorine
Link to comment
Share on other sites

01. Ray of Light

02. American Life

03. MDNA

04. Madonna

05. Confessions On A Dancefloor

06. True Blue

07. Like a Prayer

08. Erotica

09. Bedtime Stories

10. Music

11. Like a Virgin

HC is not remotely good to rank any list and never cared for I'm Breathless.

I'm Breathless is not a real Madonna album—soundtrack. Think Prince soundtrack for Batman the previous year.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm Breathless is not a real Madonna album—soundtrack. Think Prince soundtrack for Batman the previous year.

Why do we have to re-litigate this once a month? It's not a soundtrack and it's not a "proper" studio album. It's somewhere in between and everyone has their own opinion. I personally consider it a Madonna album because it's all new Madonna material, most of which isn't from the film. It's a concept album inspired by the film with three songs from the actual film, and it happens to be superior to many other Madonna albums. Batman is also both a Prince album and a soundtrack. And Mariah Carey's Glitter is both a Mariah album and a soundtrack.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why do we have to re-litigate this once a month? It's not a soundtrack and it's not a "proper" studio album. It's somewhere in between and everyone has their own opinion. I personally consider it a Madonna album because it's all new Madonna material, most of which isn't from the film. It's a concept album inspired by the film with three songs from the actual film, and it happens to be superior to many other Madonna albums. Batman is also both a Prince album and a soundtrack. And Mariah Carey's Glitter is both a Mariah album and a soundtrack.

Still it is considered a soundtrack album not a studio album itself. There are compilations, singles and live releases for example. That album was a soundtrack not a studio album that characterized a Madonna era.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I respect everyone's enthusiasm, and I'm spinning the album every day (skipping GMAYL), but I'm curious to see where this album lands on people's lists one, three, 10 years from now. I feel like a lot of us are running on adrenaline right now.

hillaryblackkidax9.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Today, 01:23 AM erotica_blu, on 27 March 2012 - 07:21 PM, said:

If it is ask yourself this. If there were no Dick Tracy would it exist?—the answer is No. Let it go.

it is. nahgirluh0.gif

smiley_acbh.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1) Erotica

2) American Life

3) Like a Prayer

4) MDNA

5) Confessions on a Dance Floor

6) True Blue

7) Ray Of Light

8) Music

9) Like a Virgin

10) Madonna

11) Bedtime Stories

12) I'M BREATHLESS

13) Hard Candy

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Perfect: Madonna + Like A Prayer + Ray Of Light

Very Good: True Blue + Erotica + COADF

Good: Like A Virgin + Bedtime Stories + Music + American Life

Meh: Hard Candy + MDNA (Sorry, I'm not that impressed :( )

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Meh: Hard Candy + MDNA (Sorry, I'm not that impressed :( )

Give it a few more listens. It took about 5 for me, then it hit me and I was blown away. Except for Love Spent and Beautiful Killer - those got me right away.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Erotica (Erotica, Fever, Bad Girl)

Bedtime Stories (Bedtime Story, Secret, Human Nature)

Music (I Deserve It, Paradise (Not for Me), Impressive Instant)

MDNA (I Fucked Up, Superstar, Best Friend)

Hard Candy (Candy Shop, She's Not Me, Miles Away)

Im Breathless (Something to Remember, Cry Baby, Hanky Panky)

American Life (American Life, X-Static Process, Mother and Father)

Madonna (Everybody, Physical Attraction, Burning Up)

Like a Virgin (Over and Over, Stay, Pretender)

True Blue (True Blue, Wheres the Party, Papa Don't Preach)

Like a Prayer (Spanish Eyes, Dear Jessie, Express Yourself)

Ray of Light (Drowned World, Frozen, Shanti)

Confessions on a Dance Floor (Hung Up, Isaac, Future Lovers)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest ItsOnlyAshleigh

Ray of Light

Like a Prayer

True Blue

Music

MDNA

Erotica

Like a Vigin

Hard Candy

Madonna

Bedtime Stories

CONADF

American Life

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Erotica (Erotica, Fever, Bad Girl)

Bedtime Stories (Bedtime Story, Secret, Human Nature)

Music (I Deserve It, Paradise (Not for Me), Gone)

MDNA (I Fucked Up, Give me all luvin', Superstar)

Hard Candy (Candy Shop, She's Not Me, Miles Away)

Im Breathless (Something to Remember, Cry Baby, Hanky Panky)

American Life (American Live, Nothing Fails, Mother and Father)

Madonna (Everybody, Physical Attraction, Burning Up)

Like a Virgin (Over and Over, Stay, Pretender)

True Blue (True Blue, Wheres the Party, Papa Don't Preach)

Like a Prayer (Spanish Eyes, Dear Jessie, Express Yourself)

Ray of Light (Drowned World, Frozen, Shanti)

Confessions on a Dance Floor (Hung Up, Isaac, Future Lovers)

They are bottom three? Congrats for being different. I love that. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sorry for this stupid query...Are the bonus tracks or the deluxe ed considered in ranking MDNA? Cause I really love I F*cked up...The track alone will place MDNA higher on my list. How I wish they included it on the standard ed instead of masterpiece. :(

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...