-
Posts
4,522 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Posts posted by Shaun
-
-
Just now, dcbyebyebaby said:
Well some of us are fans of Madonna the performer. So to me the news is a little disappointing. I suppose if she talks about the MX tour in detail I would listen.
I thought we were all fans of Madonna the performer. But if you wanna be disappointed, knock yourself out.
-
Just now, jonski43 said:
No show to herself then. Oh well.
That’s your reaction to this news?! Super excited to see this!
-
10 minutes ago, cynthia said:
From The Mirror
This isn’t even a review...
-
-
Her GLAAD speech was absolutely beautiful.
-
No. RS reviews are categorized as follows:
5 stars - Classic
4 stars - Excellent
3 stars - Good
2 stars - Fair
1 star - Poor
-
I’ve enjoyed everything about this era! Luckiest fan base ever. And we still have so much to come between the album and tour. Spoiled af.
-
-
I love that a Madonna fan page thinks the album title is Confessions on THE Dance Floor. Huge pet peeve of mine. If you can’t get details like this right, what else is incorrect?
-
Does Q count for Metacritic? I wonder when the Madame X page will appear on their site?
-
Rebel Heart came out in 2015
-
The only M album that ever disappointed me was Confessions. Drab, uninspired, and melancholy. But different strokes for different folks, eh? The other 12 have been ace.
-
-
-
Any idea how to change this thread title? @Kim, is that something you can do? Should this be called MADAME X: Official Album Reviews?
-
This gets me very excited:
"Full of experiments no other pop star on Earth would try."
-
1 hour ago, Samo said:
American Life is her worst album, just dreadful, boring, dull, uninspired songwriting, same monotonous guitar on EVERY song etc
Confessions volume 2 please Madonna?
-
I love this sentence:
”Her latest is one of her weirdest, befitting a pop queen who loves taking risks.”
-
The Frida cover art looks stunning on the printed page, though!
-
Just now, ibizaboi24 said:
American life is ass????
Right?!?! If this album is anything like AL, we’re in for quite a treat!
-
Her RS history:
Debut: no star rating
LAV: 3.5
TB: no star rating
LAP: 3.5
E: 4
BS: 3.5
ROL: 4
Music: 4
AL: 3
Confessions: 3.5
HC: 4
MDNA: 3.5
RH: 3.5
MX: 3
-
Same rating they gave American Life back in ‘03.
-
-
13 minutes ago, Bette Davis Dub said:
Some sites mentioned GC is going to be released on June 14, 2019. I had read it somewhere in this forum too, when the release dates for Medellin, I Rise, Crave, and Dark Ballet were listed. https://madonna.fandom.com/wiki/God_Control_(song)
The entire album is out on 6/14.
MADAME X: official reviews are in: MADAME X is a hit with the critics!
in ARCHIVE - The MADAME X Forum
Posted
The Guardian review irritated me.
Rolling Stone, Q, and The Guardian count for Metacritic, correct?