HOLY TRINITY | MDNA

[Bill 0]

Beautiful Killer - the top 10 single that never was.

[LVX 0]

53 minutes ago, Bill said:

Beautiful Killer - the top 10 single that never was.

And a song that was deemed more appropriate to be a leftover bonus track than Some Girls or Superstar. 

[Bill 0]

2 minutes ago, LVX said:

And a song that was deemed more appropriate to be a leftover bonus track than Some Girls or Superstar. 

Right?! I'll never understand it.

[Curtains 0]

Beautiful Killer, Love Spent and I'm Addicted.

[MCHL 0]

I'm A Dick, Ted

Love Spent

I Don't Give A... (seriously underrated) 

[Gâteau 0]

I'm Addicted (accidentally hit I'm a Sinner 😒)

Beautiful Killer

Best Friend

[Shane 0]

What kind of world when Falling Free struggles to edge out Girl Gone Wild for votes

[Maddylvr 0]

9 hours ago, Jazzy Jan said:

Well, don't come into the thread then.   I know stacks of people hate this album, but this is the thread where we list our three favourite songs from it.  There are countless other threads on this forum about hating MDNA. 

 

I'm free to speak my mind and I never said I hated the album. I actually like it when I'm in the mood for it. It's just imo not considered part of her holy grail.

[Jairo 0]

I love I'm a Dick Ted

Also, Love Spent and I Don't Give A

[Flip The Switch 0]

Falling Free / Beautiful Killer / B-Day Song

[eu4ria 0]

I never can get into Love Spent for some reason *shrugs* 

[S.E.X. 0]

24 minutes ago, Flip The Switch said:

Falling Free / Beautiful Killer / B-Day Song

You must be joking.

[Flip The Switch 0]

13 minutes ago, S.E.X. said:

You must be joking.

No, I'm not. 

[eu4ria 0]

[todsmod 0]

Love Spent

Beautiful Killer

Falling Free

Honorable Mentions:  I'm Addicted, I Don't Give A..., Girl Gone Wild, Gimme All Your Luvin', I Fucked Up, Best Friend, Masterpiece, Gang Bang.....OH HELL....all the rest!!!  

I actually loved (and still do) MDNA!!  Even B-Day Song!!  Not her most cohesive album, but plenty of stuff to love.

[Nick 0]

2 hours ago, eu4ria20 said:

This is actually very cute! Just can't believe how Madonna wasn't able to capitalize on MIA's strengths for some kilker tracks.

[dollhouse 0]

12 hours ago, Maddylvr said:

Sorry, but I don't think this album is worthy of a holy trinity 

flop fan, i bet youre a bigger Britney fan..

[wash 0]

The results so far show very clearly what the 3 singles should have been!

[Maddylvr 0]

59 minutes ago, dollhouse said:

flop fan, i bet youre a bigger Britney fan..

[dollhouse 0]

6 minutes ago, Maddylvr said:

I knew it:

[Pedro 0]

4 hours ago, Flip The Switch said:

Falling Free / Beautiful Killer / B-Day Song

 I've always liked Bday and Superstar! 

[S.E.X. 0]

Cackling at the Solveig songs flopping!  

This album really should have been produced by the Benassi brothers, William Orbit and possibly someone else...Calvin Harris or something.

[Flip The Switch 0]

5 hours ago, eu4ria20 said:

"Na na na na, na na na na na..."

[Crystal Coffin 0]

1. GIRL GONE WILD

2. SOME GIRLS 

3. BEAUTIFUL KILLER

[IsaacHarris 0]

I'm loving the love for Some Girls

 

 

IF YOU WANNA PLAY THIS GAME WITH ME...

I'M NOT LIKE ALL THE REST, SOME GIRLS ARE 2ND BEST

PUT YA LOVIN' TO THE TEST, YOU'LL SEE!!!

[swimtoshore 0]

Gang Bang

I'm Addicted

Falling Free

[Roland Barthes 0]

I did not vote for Love Spent because the acoustic version was not in the list and i can't listen to the album version anymore (the mix, the production, it completly kills the song. Why is her voice so compressed ???)

[rocknrolla 0]

I bet this album as a whole would have been much better received if it would have simply been recorded in "normal" vocals.

My theory is this whole album is about her hiding from her age.  Hiding her face behind the screen on the cover, high pitched fake youthful sounding vocals, young sounding songs.  Like she was trying to convince a new generation she was in her 20s-30s or something.

[erotica blu 0]

I Don't Give A // Falling Free // B'Day Song

The inclusion of B'Day Song is a callback to when I loved it. I also know everyone here hates it. Were there room for one more it'd be Love Spent.

[LVX 0]

1 hour ago, rocknrolla said:

I bet this album as a whole would have been much better received if it would have simply been recorded in "normal" vocals.

My theory is this whole album is about her hiding from her age.  Hiding her face behind the screen on the cover, high pitched fake youthful sounding vocals, young sounding songs.  Like she was trying to convince a new generation she was in her 20s-30s or something.

This. I was so relieved when her real voice returned on Rebel Heart.