Jump to content
MadonnaNation.com Forums

REBEL HEART ALBUM : Top 5 least favourite


Recommended Posts

The only songs that I do not think are complete tens are:

1. S.E.X. (7.0) S.E.X. is a grower though. I originally gave it a (6.0) I would rate it higher but it is hard to overlook the similarities to superior songs such as Erotica, Justify My Love, and I Want You (all perfect 10.0's ).

2. Best Night (7.5) (The speaking Justify My Love section of is song is a (10.0) This is the only song that I have not specifically played outside of the general tracklisting. I don't hate it by any means, it just feels artificially rebellious.)

3. Grafitti Heart (9.0) My highest "non ten". It is great but it feels a bit out of place. (I still love it).

4. Addicted (8.0) A few demos were tens that weren't included so I am punishing this song. Never Let You Go and Nothing Lasts Forever are brilliant yet omitted.

5. Autotune Baby (8.5) Fun but it is not a ten. What can I say....I would have rather seen Tragic Girl reworked and included. My taste only not an expert analysis.

Just my opinion. Not trying to wreck anyone's day. :) XOXOX to all rebel hearts.

Edited by sul8323
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 124
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

The Kanye songs are the weakest imo.

Illuminati (Overwrought, but inspired none the less)

Inside Out (The distortion on the chorus drum is so distracting from her beautiful melody ugh, overall boring)

Wash All Over Me (boring AF production, lack of musical dynamics, drums are flaccid)

Holy Water (worst song out of all 500 demos lol)

Rebel Heart is pretty lifeless now too, it needs that 4 on the floor disco beat!!!

Link to post
Share on other sites

They're not in a particular order, but these are my top 5 least favourite

1. S.E.X. (Embarassing lyrics, don't understand the so-called sense of humour)

2. Rebel Heart (Demo was perfect, album version is just boring)

3. Unapolagetic Bitch (Don't like the vocals, it's not that bad, but it's one of my least favorites)

4. Messiah (Don't like the production either, it's a powerless ballad)

5. Illuminatti (I just don't like it, always skip it)

Shocked at some of the opinions and tastes here

Link to post
Share on other sites

The Kanye songs are the weakest imo.

Illuminati (Overwrought, but inspired none the less)

Inside Out (The distortion on the chorus drum is so distracting from her beautiful melody ugh, overall boring)

Wash All Over Me (boring AF production, lack of musical dynamics, drums are flaccid)

Holy Water (worst song out of all 500 demos lol)

Rebel Heart is pretty lifeless now too, it needs that 4 on the floor disco beat!!!

I guess...

Veni Vidi Vici

Hold Tight

Iconic

Bitch I'm Madonna

Rebel Heart (album version only)

Based on the 19 track Deluxe version:

1. Best Night

2. Messiah

3. S.E.X.

4. Bitch,I'm Madonna

5. Rebel Heart

1. Grafitti Heart (can't stand it)

2. Wash All Over Me

3. Rebel Heart

4. Veni Vidi Vici

5. Queen (always skip, after Beautiful Scars)

They're not in a particular order, but these are my top 5 least favourite

1. S.E.X. (Embarassing lyrics, don't understand the so-called sense of humour)

2. Rebel Heart (Demo was perfect, album version is just boring)

3. Unapolagetic Bitch (Don't like the vocals, it's not that bad, but it's one of my least favorites)

4. Messiah (Don't like the production either, it's a powerless ballad)

5. Illuminatti (I just don't like it, always skip it)

Shocked at some of the opinions and tastes here

It breaks my heart that a lot of people will hear these album versions and have the same reaction as you without knowing that the demos of these three songs were LIFE!

Link to post
Share on other sites

I love pretty much every song. However, at the bottom of the pile are:

Bitch, I'm still Madonna

(I'm not) Addicted (to this song)

Borrowed Time (that I need back from listening)

Link to post
Share on other sites

1-Hold Tight (kinda generic and a Baby Don't Lie twin)

2-S.E.X. (It's not sexy and it fails if it's tongue and cheek, the only good part is the rap)

3-Best Night (also generic the lyrics are great but the melody don't)

4-Body Shop (corny as hell, I've been saying that it is Superstar 2.0)

5-Autotune Fetus

6- Grafitti Heart ( it's a filler that it wasn't needed)

She should have put Borrowed Time, Addicted, Beautiful Scars, Nothing Last Forever and Take a Day in the Deluxe Version or even in the Standard.

She focused in a lot of songs and per se the album is not that cohesive like COADF or Music, I know that it was supposed to be a double album but I don't know, there's some off.

I'm seriously considering to replace WAOM and RH album versions with the demos, I was so excited when they surfaced in November:( which ones are the best demos? I only have the first ones that leaked in November.

Link to post
Share on other sites

It's ridiculous how these kind of threads make me hate people. I'm bitch slapping myself saying "Come on they are entitled to their opinions, it's just songs" but i still want you all dead. :laugh::laugh::laugh:

:thumbsup:

Anyone who includes Best Night in their bottom 5 I can't take seriously.

Personally I love every song on the album but the only ones I don't listen to as much as the others is Wash All Over Me and Messiah.

Link to post
Share on other sites

1 - BIM

2 - Messiah

3 - Ghosttown

4 - Addicted

5 - Graffitti Heart

The first three are among her best in a long time. WOW! I do respect your opinion though.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I love pretty much every song. However, at the bottom of the pile are:

Bitch, I'm still Madonna

(I'm not) Addicted (to this song)

Borrowed Time (that I need back from listening)

Borrowed Time is my # 1 favorite. Sorry. I guess she included it for me and not you. LOL

Link to post
Share on other sites

Honestly, there is no song I dislike.

My least favorite are:

BITCH, I'M MADONNA

HOLY WATER

BODY SHOP

BEST NIGHT

Link to post
Share on other sites

honestly i love them all...even the bonus cuts. it has nothing to do with my adoration for M....even if some other artist recorded RH i'd be obsessed with it. it's a fucking brilliant album.

and i CAN'T with all the hate for 'best night', 'messiah', and 'borrowed time'!!! those are amazing songs!

and sorry....the SEX songs are LIFE. :sassy:

Edited by MDonner
Link to post
Share on other sites

Hm least favourite so i'd go with:

  1. Autotune baby ( The only one i don't like it)
  2. Body shop
  3. Beautiful Scars
  4. Graffiti Heart

To be honest 2,3,4 are my least played but still like them.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I like every song, but if I have to make a list:

1. Illuminati

2. Beautiful Scars

3. Bitch I'm Madonna

4. Hold Tight

Illuminati is the only one that I occasionally skip when I play the album.

Link to post
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...