Jump to content
MadonnaNation.com Forums

What do you rate each Rebel Heart track?


Recommended Posts

For me there are no duds on this album and it is her best since Ray Of Light


But I'm not as impressed with the tongue in cheek sexy songs so much:



1. Living For Love: 7


2. Devil Pray: 10


3. Ghosttown: 10


4. Unapologetic Bitch: 9


5. Illuminati: 5


6. Bitch, I'm Madonna: 6


7. Hold Tight: 8


8. Joan of Arc: 10


9. Iconic: 7


10. HeartBreakCity: 10


11. Body Shop: 9


12. Holy Water: 5


13. Inside Out: 10


14. Wash All Over Me: 10


15. Best Night: 9


16. Veni, Vedi, Vici: 8


17. S.E.X.: 7


18. Messiah: 10


19. Rebel Heart: 10



20. Beautiful Scars: 8


21. Borrowed Time: 7


22. Addicted: 10


23. Graffiti Heart: 7



24 Queen: 10

25 Autotune Baby: 7

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 94
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Guest rocketman

1. Living For Love [10]


2. Devil Pray [9]


3. Ghosttown [10]


4. Unapologetic Bitch [8]


5. Illuminati [8]


6. Bitch, I'm Madonna [8]


7. Hold Tight [8]


8. Joan of Arc [10]


9. Iconic [10]


10. HeartBreakCity [6]


11. Body Shop [8]


12. Holy Water [7]


13. Inside Out [9]


14. Wash All Over Me [10]


15. Best Night [8]


16. Veni, Vedi, Vici [8]


17. S.E.X. [5]


18. Messiah [8]


19. Rebel Heart [8]



Bonus Tracks



20. Beautiful Scars [9]


21. Borrowed Time [9]


22. Addicted [10]


23. Graffiti Heart [7]




24. Autotune Baby [8]


25. Queen [10] * should've closed the album


Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Living For Love- 10

2. Devil Pray - 9

3. Ghosttown - 9

4. Unapolagetic Bitch - 9

5. Illuminati - 10

6. Bitch I'm Madonna - 8

7. Hold Tight - 7

8. Joan of Arc - 9

9. Iconic - 9

10. Heartbreak City - 9

11. Body Shop -10

12. Holy Water - 9

13. Inside Out -10

14. Wash All Over Me -10

15. Best Night -10

16. Veni Vidi Vici -10

17. S.E.X. - 8

18. Messiah - 8

19. Rebel Heart - 9

Bonus Tracks

20. Beautiful Scars - 9

21. Queen - 10,000,000 LYFE giving, criminal its disappeared

22. Borrowed Time -8

23. Graffiti Heart - 8

24. Autotune Baby - 6

25. Addicted - 7

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Living for Love: 9

2. Devil Pray 10

3. Ghosttown 10

4. Unapologetic Bitch 8

5. Illuminati 8

6. Bitch I'm Madonna 7

7. Hold Tight 9

8. Joan of Arc 10

9. Iconic 10

10. Heartbreak City 9

11. Body Shop 9

12. Holy Water 10

13. Inside Out 10

14. Wash All Over Me 10

15. Best Night 8

16. Veni Vidi Vici 10

17. S.E.X. 7.5

18. Messiah 10

19. Rebel Heart 10

20. Beautiful Scars 9

21. Borrowed Time 10

22. Addicted 10

23. Graffiti Heart 9

Album 10

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest whatatramp

1. Living For Love [10]

2. Devil Pray [10]
3. Ghosttown [10]
4. Unapologetic Bitch [9]
5. Illuminati [10]
6. Bitch, I'm Madonna [10]
7. Hold Tight [7]
8. Joan of Arc [9]
9. Iconic [9]
10. HeartBreakCity [10]
11. Body Shop [7]
12. Holy Water [10]
13. Inside Out [8]
14. Wash All Over Me [8]
15. Best Night [7]
16. Veni, Vedi, Vici [9]
17. S.E.X. [10]
18. Messiah [9]
19. Rebel Heart [8]
I'm not doing bonus tracks, some 7's & 8's are bound to go up
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Living for Love - 8

2. Devil Pray - 10

3. Ghosttown - 10

4. Unapologetic Bitch - 9

5. Illuminati - 7

6. Bitch I'm Madonna - 6

7. Hold Tight - 9

8. Joan of Arc - 9.5

9. Iconic - 9

10. Heartbreak City - 9

11. Body Shop -5

12. Holy Water - 10

13. Inside Out -10

14. Wash All Over Me -9.5

15. Best Night -8.5

16. Veni Vidi Vici -8

17. S.E.X. - 6

18. Messiah - 10

19. Rebel Heart - 9

Bonus Tracks

20. Beautiful Scars - 8

21. Queen (sorry I don't get it) 7

22. Borrowed Time -10

23. Graffiti Heart - 8

24. Autotune Baby - 9

25. Addicted - 10

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Living For Love - 6,5

2. Devil Pray - 11

3. Ghosttown - 10

4. Unapolagetic Bitch - 8,5

5. Illuminati - 8

6. Bitch I'm Madonna - 11

7. Hold Tight - 9

8. Joan of Arc - 12

9. Iconic - 6

10. Heartbreak City - 12

11. Body Shop - 11

12. Holy Water - 7

13. Inside Out - 10

14. Wash All Over Me - 12

15. Best Night - 8

16. Veni Vidi Vici - 9

17. S.E.X. - 6,5

18. Messiah - 7,5

19. Rebel Heart - 10

Bonus Tracks

20. Beautiful Scars 9
21. Borrowed Time 10
22. Addicted 10
23. Graffiti Heart 9

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Living For Love - 9

2. Devil Pray - 8

3. Ghosttown - 8

4. Unapologetic Bitch - 5

5. Illuminati - 4

6. Bitch I'm Madonna - 7

7. Hold Tight - 9

8. Joan of Arc - 10

9. Iconic - 7

10. HeartBreakCity - 3

11. Body Shop - 9

12. Holy Water - 8

13. Inside Out - 6

14. Wash All Over Me - 10

15. Best Night - 6

16. Veni Vidi Vici - 7

17. S.E.X. - 7

18. Messiah - 9

19. Rebel Heart - 5

20. Beautiful Scars - 6

21. Borrowed Time - 4

22. Graffiti Heart - 8

23. Addicted - 8

24. Queen - 6

25. Auto-tune Baby - 7

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Living For Love - 8


2. Devil Pray - 8


3. Ghosttown - 10


4. Unapologetic Bitch - 10


5. Illuminati - 10


6. Bitch I'm Madonna - 10


7. Hold Tight - 7


8. Joan of Arc - 7


9. Iconic - 4


10. Heartbreak City - 10


11. Body Shop - 10


12. Holy Water - 10


13. Inside Out - 10


14. Wash All Over Me - 10


15. Best Night - 10


16. Veni Vidi Vici - 7


17. S.E.X. - 7


18. Messiah - 10


19. Rebel Heart - 8


20. Beautiful Scars - 10 - If I could give it a 15, I would.


21. Borrowed Time - 9


22. Graffiti Heart - 8


23. Addicted - 10



I will rate the demos later. I want to enjoy the magic I got today for a while.


Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Living For Love - 8

2. Devil Pray - 8

3. Ghosttown - 10

4. Unapologetic Bitch - 10

5. Illuminati - 10

6. Bitch I'm Madonna - 11

7. Hold Tight - 7

8. Joan of Arc - 7

9. Iconic - 4

10. Heartbreak City - 10

11. Body Shop - 8

12. Holy Water - 7

13. Inside Out - 10

14. Wash All Over Me - 10

15. Best Night - 9

16. Veni Vidi Vici - 7

17. S.E.X. - 7

18. Messiah - 10

19. Rebel Heart - 8

20. Beautiful Scars - 15

21. Borrowed Time - 9

22. Graffiti Heart - 8

23. Addicted - 10

I will rate the demos later. I want to enjoy the magic I got today for a while.

You have exquisite taste.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Living For Love [8]

2. Devil Pray [10]

3. Ghosttown [9]

4. Unapologetic Bitch [7]

5. Illuminati [7]

6. Bitch, I'm Madonna [10]

7. Hold Tight [9]

8. Joan of Arc [8]

9. Iconic [9]

10. HeartBreakCity [7]

11. Body Shop [3]

12. Holy Water [10]

13. Inside Out [10]

14. Wash All Over Me [7]

15. Best Night [7]

16. Veni, Vedi, Vici [7]

17. S.E.X. [5]

18. Messiah [4]

19. Rebel Heart [7]

Bonus Tracks

20. Beautiful Scars [8]

21. Borrowed Time [5]

22. Addicted [10]

23. Graffiti Heart [6]

24. Queen [6]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Living For Love - 8
2. Devil Pray - 10
3. Ghosttown - 10
4. Unapologetic Bitch - 6
5. Illuminati - 7
6. Bitch I'm Madonna - 8
7. Hold Tight - 10
8. Joan of Arc - 10
9. Iconic - 9
10. Heartbreak City - 10
11. Body Shop - 10
12. Holy Water - 7
13. Inside Out - 8
14. Wash All Over Me - 10
15. Best Night - 10
16. Veni Vidi Vici - 7
17. S.E.X. - 6
18. Messiah - 9
19. Rebel Heart - 8
20. Beautiful Scars - 8
21. Borrowed Time - 10
22. Graffiti Heart - 8
23. Addicted - 10

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Living For Love [8]


2. Devil Pray [10]


3. Ghosttown [10]


4. Unapologetic Bitch [10]


5. Illuminati [8]


6. Bitch, I'm Madonna [8]


7. Hold Tight [10]


8. Joan of Arc [10]


9. Iconic [10]


10. HeartBreakCity [10]


11. Body Shop [10]


12. Holy Water [10]


13. Inside Out [10]


14. Wash All Over Me [10]


15. Best Night [10]


16. Veni, Vedi, Vici [9]


17. S.E.X. [9]


18. Messiah [10]


19. Rebel Heart [10]



Bonus Tracks



20. Beautiful Scars [10]


21. Borrowed Time [7]


22. Addicted [7]


23. Graffiti Heart [10]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Living For Love [8]

2. Devil Pray [10]

3. Ghosttown [10]

4. Unapologetic Bitch [10]

5. Illuminati [8]

6. Bitch, I'm Madonna [8]

7. Hold Tight [10]

8. Joan of Arc [10]

9. Iconic [10]

10. HeartBreakCity [10]

11. Body Shop [10]

12. Holy Water [10]

13. Inside Out [10]

14. Wash All Over Me [10]

15. Best Night [10]

16. Veni, Vedi, Vici [9]

17. S.E.X. [9]

18. Messiah [10]

19. Rebel Heart [10]

Bonus Tracks

20. Beautiful Scars [10]

21. Borrowed Time [7]

22. Addicted [7]

23. Graffiti Heart [10]

:clap:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

A little late to the party but after a few listens here's how my rankings currently stand:

1. Living For Love [10]

2. Devil Pray [10]

3. Ghosttown [10]

4. Unapologetic Bitch [7]

5. Illuminati [8]

6. Bitch, I'm Madonna [7]

7. Hold Tight [8]

8. Joan of Arc [10]

9. Iconic [8]

10. HeartBreakCity [9]

11. Body Shop [9]

12. Holy Water [6]

13. Inside Out [10]

14. Wash All Over Me [10]

15. Best Night [7]

16. Veni, Vedi, Vici [8]

17. S.E.X. [8]

18. Messiah [9]

19. Rebel Heart [10]

Bonus Tracks

20. Beautiful Scars [9]

21. Borrowed Time [8]

22. Addicted [9]

23. Graffiti Heart [9]

Demos

24. Queen [8]

25. Autotune Baby [6]

26. Alone With You [10]

27. Trust No Bitch [7]

28. Heaven [10]

29. Take a Day [8]

30. Two Steps Behind [10]

31. Never Let You Go [8]

32. Tragic Girl [9]

33. God Is Love [6]

34. Freedom [8]

35. Score [6]

36. Take it Back [5]

37. Revolution [9]

38. Nothing Lasts Forever [8]

39. Back it Up [7]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Living For Love [10]


2. Devil Pray [8]


3. Ghosttown [8]


4. Unapologetic Bitch [8]


5. Illuminati [5]


6. Bitch, I'm Madonna [6]


7. Hold Tight [8]


8. Joan of Arc [9]


9. Iconic [6]


10. HeartBreakCity [8]


11. Body Shop [10]


12. Holy Water [6]


13. Inside Out [9]


14. Wash All Over Me [10]


15. Best Night [10]


16. Veni, Vedi, Vici [8]


17. S.E.X. [8]


18. Messiah [9]


19. Rebel Heart [9]



Bonus Tracks



20. Beautiful Scars [7]


21. Borrowed Time [9]


22. Addicted [6]


23. Graffiti Heart [7]


Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree, I haven't enjoyed so much a Madonna album since Confessions. Here's my rating:

1. Living For Love [9] It would be a 10 if they had kept the "lord lord lift me, god forgive me" part.

2. Devil Pray [10]

3. Ghosttown [9]

4. Unapologetic Bitch [10]

5. Illuminati [7]

6. Bitch, I'm Madonna [8]

7. Hold Tight [9]

8. Joan of Arc [9]

9. Iconic [10]

10. HeartBreakCity [9]

11. Body Shop [8]

12. Holy Water [7]

13. Inside Out [10]

14. Wash All Over Me [9]

15. Best Night [8]

16. Veni, Vedi, Vici [8]

17. S.E.X. [8]

18. Messiah [10]

19. Rebel Heart [9] Again, it would be a 10 if they had kept some elements from the demo, I hate being spoiled by those stupid demos.

Bonus Tracks

20. Beautiful Scars [8]

21. Borrowed Time [8]

22. Addicted [9]

23. Graffiti Heart [7]

24. Queen [8]

25. Autotune Baby [8]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Living For Love [10]


2. Devil Pray [9]


3. Ghosttown [10]


4. Unapologetic Bitch [8]


5. Illuminati [5]


6. Bitch, I'm Madonna [8]


7. Hold Tight [10]


8. Joan of Arc [10]


9. Iconic [9]


10. HeartBreakCity [10]


11. Body Shop [8]


12. Holy Water [9]


13. Inside Out [9]


14. Wash All Over Me [8]


15. Best Night [10]


16. Veni, Vedi, Vici [8]


17. S.E.X. [7]


18. Messiah [10]


19. Rebel Heart [10]



Bonus Tracks



20. Beautiful Scars [8]


21. Borrowed Time [10]


22. Addicted [8]


23. Graffiti Heart [9]


24. Autotune Baby [0]


25. Queen [8]


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ok, after having listened to it for full 10 days, here's my current rating...Keep in mind though it might look different the next day again :lol: Still need more time for an 'absolute' rating...

1. Living For Love [10]

2. Devil Pray [9]

3. Ghosttown [10]

4. Unapologetic Bitch [9]

5. Illuminati [8]

6. Bitch I'm Madonna [5]

7. Hold Tight [8]

8. Joan Of Arc [10]

9. Iconic [9]

10. HeartBreakCity [9]

11. Body Shop [7]

12. Holy Water [8]

13. Inside Out [10]

14. Wash All Over Me [10]

15. Best Night [10]

16. Veni Vidi Vici [9]

17. S.E.X. [8]

18. Messiah [10]

19. Rebel Heart [9]

20. Beautiful Scars [9]

21. Borrowed Time [10]

22. Addicted [8]

23. Graffiti Heart [8]

24. Auto-Tune Baby [7]

( 25. Queen [10] )

Which makes for an average of 9/10 for the album :clap:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Living For Love Love when the piano kicks in. Sounds robotic sometimes. Her voice in the chorus! Madonna is determined to move in a positive direction. Makes me feel better when down. 9

Devil Pray It feels nostaligic. Like going back in time. Madonna knows all too well what addiction can do to people and possibly what causes it. The guitar! Her voice is crystal clear! Not completely feeling the distorted voice. It's cool. 9

Ghosttown Heart! Beautiful tone to Madonna's voice. Strong and lovely. Caring. People need to hear it. Mad mad mad world a slight too much? 9 1/2

Unapologetic Bitch Love the chorus. Love the little "did you?" It gets better as it goes along. It seems like it grows in intensity. Grown on me the most. "Little" tedious overall. 8 1/2

Illuminati Love the robotic voice only for the effect. Like when she plays roles in songs. It's fun to listen to. It's a little without feeling but of course it is. 8

Bitch I'm Madonna Sarcastic, which I confess I love. My dark side. The music is great. I love the teasing. I love the lyrics. I feel as if the "who do you think you are" can be asked by the critic and the one being criticized. That's my absolute favorite part of the song and I find that intensely empowering. Nicki is wonderful. We go hard or we go home<---love that. You're gonna love this, cant touch this...not so much. There is a huge difference in having confidence in who you are and thinking you are better than everyone. Bitch I'm Madonna and I'm proud of it. 9

Hold Tight I usually don't like power ballads which this almost sounds like. Love the Ray of Lightish intro. Anthemic, typical 80's, This song represents the best of those though. Bridge is exceptional. 8 1/2

Joan Of ArcI don't like overly sappy expressed songs which I think takes way from the strong feelings they are talking about. Like I love the deep emotions but I am more critical at how they are expressed. What's funny about Joan Of Arc is her expressing deep feelings in a very laid back almost Carole King kind of vibe way. I kinda like the upbeat sound with the lyrics though. I especially like "I can't be a superhero right now." I don't understand the "not yet" unless she is saying I am not yet that strong. It's an exceptional song overall though. 9

Iconic Love the message. Should be played at every self help get together. The chorus is glorious! Not sure what the ironic means. Maybe feeling like this inspite of insecurities? The song has powerful energy and feels like a single to me. 9

Heartbreak City The only one I can't get into although I can see the quality. I think I would like this better with just a piano. The music almost makes it sound like it's trying to sound empowering. Very dramatic and a good example of how I perceive the feelings expressed. She sounds like she is taking on a role. 7

Body Shop Breezy, clever, like the light sounds. A welcome relief after the sadness in Heartbreak City. 9

Holy Water It's catchy. I don't get the overly explicit lyrics. I love the bless yourself and genuflect. I think that's funny. I like the Bitch get off my pole too. Not a fan of the chorus? 7 1/2

Inside Out I love when this song starts. One of the biggest heart songs on the album. Bothers me a little when it seems to want to go into another direction at moments in the song. Beautiful bridge. Would love to hear an acoustic version. 8 1/2

Wash All Over Me LOVE LOVE LOVE the opening lyrics in this song. I could stand there and recite the lyrics. Love the beauty in the chorus. The lyrics throughout. Love the gentle but powerful music during the verses. The music in the chorus becomes more encompassing but the feeling is so powerful that it works. 10

Best Night Very Relaxed and nice to hear. Sexy, love the background music. This is the most Bedtime Stories song I hear on the album. Nice ambience. 7 1/2

Veni Vidi Vici catchy and sweet. The inclusion of the song titles is cool but it's not why I like it. Love the "music saved my life, "and Nas expressing it as well to cross with Madonna's experience and then goes into his own personal experience. I like the different energies. 8 1/2

S.E.X. I actually find this funnier than Holy Water. I like the elements included. Funny, almost making it scary. Without taking away the genuine integrity of the human experience of sex, people sometimes take it way too seriously. 7 1/2

Messiah This one grabs me instantly. LOVE LOVE LOVE the heartbeat. A hint of melancholy, mysterious, mystical, quiet determination. Beautiful inclusion of the orchestra. It's my Falling Free of this album. There are some intense ponderings in Madonna that I love hearing expressed whether they are her own or taking on a role. 10

Rebel Heart It represents Madonna as she was from the beginning and still is and also the duality of the album. I like the even expression in the song. It's comforting. 9

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Living For Love Love when the piano kicks in. Sounds robotic sometimes. Her voice in the chorus! Madonna is determined to move in a positive direction. Makes me feel better when down. 9

Devil PrayIt feels nostaligic. Like going back in time. Madonna knows all too well what addiction can do to people and possibly what causes it. The guitar! Her voice is crystal clear! Not completely feeling the distorted voice. It's cool 9

GhosttownHeart! Beautiful tone to Madonna's voice. Strong and lovely. Caring. People need to hear it. Mad mad mad world a slight too much? 9 1/2

Unapologetic Bitch Love the chorus. Love the little "did you?" It gets better as goes along. It seems like it grows in intensity. Grown on me the most. "Little" tedious overall. 8 1/2

Illuminati Love the robotic voice only for the effect. Like when she plays roles in songs. It's fun to listen to. It's a little without feeling but of course it is. 8

Bitch I'm MadonnaSarcastic, which I confess I love. My dark side. The music is great. I love the teasing. I love the lyrics. I feel as if the "who do you think you are can be asked by the critic and the one being criticized. That's my absolute favorite part of the song and I find that intensely empowering. Nicki is wonderful We go hard or we go home<---love that. You're gonna love this, cant touch this...not so much. There is a huge difference in having confidence in who you are and thinking you are better than everyone. Bitch I'm Madonna and I'm proud of it. 9

Hold TightI usually don't like power ballads which this almost sounds like one to me. Love the Ray of Lightish intro. Anthemic, typical 80's, This song represents the best of those though. Bridge is exceptional. 8 1/2

Joan Of ArcI don't like overly sappy expressed songs which I think takes way from the strong feelings they are talking about. Like I love the deep emotions but I am more critical at how tbey are expressed. What's funny about Joan Of Arc is her expressing deep feelings in a very laid back almost Carole King kind of vibe way. I kinda like the upbeat sound with the lyrics though. I especially like I can't be a superhero right now. I don't understand tbe not yet unless she is saying I am not yet that strong. It's an exceptional song overall though. 9

IconicLove The message. Should be played at every self help get together. The chorus is glorious! Not sure what the ironic means. Maybe feeling like this inspite of insecurities? The song has powerful energy and feels like single to me. 9

Heartbreak City The only one I can't get into although I can see the quality. I think I would like this better with just a piano. The music almost makes it sound like it's trying to sound empowering. Very dramatic and a good example of how I perceive the feelings expressed. She sounds like she is taking on a role. 7

Body Shop breezy, clever, like the light sounds. A welcome relief after the sadness in Heartbreak City. 9

Holy Water It's catchy. I don't get the overly explicit lyrics. I love the bless yourself and genuflect. I think that's funny. I like the Bitch get off my pole too. Not a fan of the chorus? 7 1/2

nside Out I love when this song starts. One of the biggest heart songs on the album. Bothers me a little when it seems to want to go into another direction at moments in the song. Beautiful bridge. Would love to hear an acoustic version. 8 1/2

Wash All Over Me LOVE LOVE LOVE the opening lyrics in this song. I could stand there and recite the lyrics. Love the beauty in the chorus. The lyrics throughout. Love the gentle but powerful music during the verses. The music in the chorus becomes more encompassing but the feeling is so powerful and that it works. 10

Best Night Very Relaxed and nice to hear. Sexy, love the background music. This is the most Bedtime Stories song I hear on the album. Nice ambience. 7 1/2

Veni Vidi Vici catchy and sweet. The inclusion of the song titles is cool but it's not why I like it. Love the "music saved my life, "and Nas expressing it as well to cross with Madonna's experience and then goes into his own personal experience. I like the different energies. 8 1/2

S.E.X. I actually find this funnier than Holy Water. I like the elements included. Funny, almost making it scary. Without taking away the genuine integrity of the human experience of sex, people sometimes take it way too seriously. 7 1/2

Messiah This one grabs me instantly. LOVE LOVE LOVE the heartbeat. A hint of melancholy, mysterious, mystical, quiet determination. Beautiful inclusion of the orchestra. It's my Falling Free of this album. There are some intense ponderings in Madonna that I love hearing expressed whether they are her own or taking on a role. 10

Rebel HeartIt represents Madonna as she was from the beginning and still is and also the duality of the album. I like the even expression in the song. It's comforting. 9

I would like to say that I truly, truly loves reading your assessments. I love when fans take the time to discuss the music. We have very similar tastes, and I especially love your reviews of Wash All Over Me and Messiah. I like your comparison of JOA to Carole King's songwriting style. Only thing I disagree is that I love the production of Inside Out. It's neat to have a classic Madonna melody with dark industrial production.

Thank you!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would like to say that I truly, truly loves reading your assessments. I love when fans take the time to discuss the music. We have very similar tastes, and I especially love your reviews of Wash All Over Me and Messiah. I like your comparison of JOA to Carole King's songwriting style. Only thing I disagree is that I love the production of Inside Out. It's neat to have a classic Madonna melody with dark industrial production.

Thank you!

Thank you! I feel the same about your posts.

The thing with this album for me is that I am finding elements I really love in every song. For instance I adore the very beginning of Heartbreak city. This is how I feel about it this morning.

Thanks for your thoughts on Inside Out.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Living For Love 8

2. Devil Pray 9

3. Ghosttown 9

4. Unapologetic Bitch 7

5. Illuminati 7

6. Bitch, I'm Madonna 6

7. Hold Tight 8

8. Joan of Arc 10

9. Iconic 7

10. HeartBreakCity 8

11. Body Shop 10

12. Holy Water 9

13. Inside Out 8

14. Wash All Over Me 10

15. Best Night 7

16. Veni, Vedi, Vici 7

17. S.E.X. 7

18. Messiah 8

19. Rebel Heart 9

Bonus Tracks

20. Beautiful Scars 9

21. Borrowed Time 9

22. Addicted 9

23. Graffiti Heart 7

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Living For Love - 10

2. Devil Pray - 10

3. Ghosttown - 10

4. Unapologetic Bitch - 9

5. Illuminati - 10

6. Bitch, I'm Madonna - 9

7. Hold Tight - 8

8. Joan of Arc (Album Version)* - 6

9. Iconic - 10

10. HeartBreakCity - 7

11. Body Shop - 10

12. Holy Water - 10

13. Inside Out - 10

14. Wash All Over Me - 10

15. Best Night - 9

16. Veni, Vedi, Vici - 7

17. S.E.X. - 9

18. Messiah - 8

19. Rebel Heart (Album Version)* - 6

Bonus Tracks

20. Beautiful Scars (Album Version)* - 6

21. Borrowed Time - 7

22. Addicted - 8

23. Graffiti Heart - 8

24. Queen - 9

25. Autotune Baby - 8


* Original/Demo versions:

Joan Of Arc (Acoustic Demo) - 10
Rebel Heart (Avicii's Cum) - 10
Beautiful Scars (Beautiful Leaked Version) - 10

The only other demo that I'm going to rank and THAT SHOULD'VE BEEN IN THE ALBUM:


Never Let You Go - 10

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So, this is how the album looks like with my 10s only:

1. Living For Love
2. Devil Pray
3. Ghosttown
4. Illuminati
5. Joan Of Arc (Acoustic)
6. Never Let You Go
7. Iconic
8. Body Shop
9. Beautiful Scars (Original/Demo)
10. Holy Water
11. Inside Out
12. Wash All Over Me
13. Rebel Heart (Original/Demo)

Pretty nice!
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 Share


×
×
  • Create New...