Jump to content

JOAN OF ARC


CJM

Recommended Posts

  • 3 weeks later...
Guest Medoner

I cant be the only one who thinks her voice just isnt loud or clear enough in some RH tracks and this song is one of the worst cases! I hope im alone with this tho. And the random fast beat thats thrown on top of all the acoustic-y stuff sounds like it was made in a minute. I sound like such a hater but i just dont get this song arghh

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I cant be the only one who thinks her voice just isnt loud or clear enough in some RH tracks and this song is one of the worst cases! I hope im alone with this tho. And the random fast beat thats thrown on top of all the acoustic-y stuff sounds like it was made in a minute. I sound like such a hater but i just dont get this song arghh

Yes the fast beat doesnt fit at all

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not sure it doesn't "fit." It just doesn't sound organic to the song, because it probably isn't (added much later).

To me this song is magnificent regardless, although I'm reeeeaaaallly excited about the prospect of hearing the pop-rock epic version she sang on Ellen!!!! Talk about a "crying moment"!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

THE ACOUSTIC VERSION IS EPIC! Love the final version, but those sounds with the guitar and the drums!!! :wow: acoustic performance is EPIC! EPIC EPIC EPIC!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

While i like the acoustic and demos, I think the album version is the best - a mix of sadness and hope (provided by the uptempo/beats) which is what the message of the song is.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ever since demos started leaking (since the Music era?) I've never been the type of fan who prefers them over the final product...until hearing RH and JoA

Obviously Madonna felt going back to the orginal version would connect more with the audience in her first US performance so hopefully she sticks to it for the tour, less is more

Link to comment
Share on other sites

^The simple, acoustic, original version of Joan of Arc...should have been left like this in the first place and NEVER made upbeat in the final version imo

I agree with you, but I just wanted the opportunity to post this pic:

081caaead5acc1eeff94bb1691c1074do.png

:)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

lol i remember the first time i showed madonna to my little brother (when he started to talk and realise things that are going on etc) and he thought madonna was 25 years old and so beautiful. ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Joan Of Arc is the best song on Rebel Heart.

Love Spent is the best song on MDNA.

Devil Wouldn't Recognize You is the best song on Hard Candy.

Get Together is the best song on COADF.

Die Another Day is the best song from American Life.

Don't Tell Me is the best song on Music.

This is 2000-2015.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Joan Of Arc is the best song on Rebel Heart.

Love Spent is the best song on MDNA.

Devil Wouldn't Recognize You is the best song on Hard Candy.

Get Together is the best song on COADF.

Die Another Day is the best song from American Life.

Don't Tell Me is the best song on Music.

This is 2000-2015.

Excellent taste but I have to go with Love Profusion (although I love Die Another Day) and I'm a Sinner (almost a tie with Love Spent).

Edited by sul8323
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think the only one I agree on is Love Spent.

Joan Of Arc is the best song on Rebel Heart.

Love Spent is the best song on MDNA.

Devil Wouldn't Recognize You is the best song on Hard Candy.

Get Together is the best song on COADF.

Die Another Day is the best song from American Life.

Don't Tell Me is the best song on Music.

This is 2000-2015.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Pud Whacker

Joan Of Arc is the best song on Rebel Heart.

Love Spent is the best song on MDNA.

Devil Wouldn't Recognize You is the best song on Hard Candy.

Get Together is the best song on COADF.

Die Another Day is the best song from American Life.

Don't Tell Me is the best song on Music.

This is 2000-2015.

Give It 2 Me on HC and its perfect.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Pud Whacker

...and Give It 2 Me (feat. Pharrell) peaked only US #57, and it pre-dates sound-alike Blurred Lines (feat. Pharrell) which was a huge #1 US hit!

isnt that appalling? best song. :thumbsup:

#JusticeForGiveIt2Me!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

M has a fantastic catalog.

My faves 83-present......

Borderline

Angel [Extended Dance Mix]

Open Your Heart

Like a Prayer

Justify My Love

Deeper and Deeper

Secret

You’ll See

You Must Love Me

Frozen

Don’t Tell Me

Love Profusion [Headcleanr Rock Mix]

Let it Will Be (Paper Faces Mix)

Devil Wouldn’t Recognize You

I’m a Sinner (William Orbit Mix)

Messiah

Queen

Joan of Arc certainly follows this trend. Long live the Queen.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

M has a fantastic catalog.

My faves 83-present......

Borderline

Angel [Extended Dance Mix]

Open Your Heart

Like a Prayer

Justify My Love

Deeper and Deeper

Secret

You’ll See

You Must Love Me

Frozen

Don’t Tell Me

Love Profusion [Headcleanr Rock Mix]

Let it Will Be (Paper Faces Mix)

Devil Wouldn’t Recognize You

I’m a Sinner (William Orbit Mix)

Messiah

Queen

Joan of Arc certainly follows this trend. Long live the Queen.

Hey I haven't even heard " Angel [Extended Dance Mix]" and "I’m a Sinner (William Orbit Mix)" till now. Thanx man!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest bluejean

I can honestly say now the dust has settled I prefer the FINAL album version of Joan of Arc. I hope she does this version on the tour!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Pud Whacker

I can honestly say now the dust has settled I prefer the FINAL album version of Joan of Arc. I hope she does this version on the tour!

Of course. The final version has LIFE!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...