Jump to content
MadonnaNation.com Forums
Sign in to follow this  
Guest Xanthium

Review/Rate/Rank MDNA

Recommended Posts

GIRL GONE WILD - 6/10

GANG BANG - 8/10

I'M ADDICTED - 10/10

TURN UP THE RADIO - 8/10

GIVE ME ALL YOUR LUVIN - 5/10

SOME GIRLS - 8/10

SUPERSTAR - 5/10

I DON'T GIVE A - 10/10

I AM A SINNER - 6/10

LOVE SPENT - 10/10

MASTERPIECE - 9/10

FALLING FREE - 10/10

BEAUTIFUL KILLER - 9/10

I F**K UP - 8/10

B DAY SONG - 5/10

BEST FRIEND - 10/10

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Rank Of Each Song.

1. Love Spent (Acoustic) & Love Spent (album version)

2. Falling Free

3. Turn Up The Radio

4. Masterpiece

5. Gang Bang/Some Girls

6. I Fucked Up/ I Don't Give A

7. B'Day Song

8. Girl Gone Wild

9. Give Me All Your Luvin'

10. Superstar

11. Best Friend

12. Beautiful Killer

13. I'm A Sinner

14. I'm Addicted

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest rocketman

GIRL GONE WILD - 8/10

GANG BANG - 9/10

I'M ADDICTED - 8.5/10

TURN UP THE RADIO - 10/10

GIVE ME ALL YOUR LUVIN - 7/10

SOME GIRLS - 8/10

SUPERSTAR - 10/10

I DON'T GIVE A - 9/10

I AM A SINNER - 10/10

LOVE SPENT - 10/10

MASTERPIECE - 10/10

FALLING FREE - 10/10

BEAUTIFUL KILLER - 10/10

I F**K UP - 10/10

B DAY SONG - 8/10

BEST FRIEND - 6.5/10

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

GIRL GONE WILD - 8/10

GANG BANG - 9/10

I'M ADDICTED - 10/10

TURN UP THE RADIO - 8/10

GIVE ME ALL YOUR LUVIN - 6/10

SOME GIRLS - 6/10

SUPERSTAR - 7/10

I DON'T GIVE A - 8/10

I AM A SINNER - 9/10

LOVE SPENT - 10/10

MASTERPIECE - 8/10

FALLING FREE - 10/10

BEAUTIFUL KILLER - 10/10

I F**K UP - 9/10

B DAY SONG - 7/10

BEST FRIEND - 5/10

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Brilliant

The have that 'Madonna factor'; they overjoy me; I have been moved to some bodily reaction - tears, maniacal laugh, sexy strike-a-pose, imitating Madonna, etc. Wouldn't change a thing.

Love Spent

Falling Free

Beautiful Killer

Gang Bang

I'm Addicted

I'm a Sinner

Excellent

The have that 'Madonna factor'; they overjoy me; I have been moved to some bodily reaction - tears, maniacal laugh, sexy strike-a-pose, imitating Madonna, etc. BUT I something's missing or I would change something about the vocal arrangement, production, etc.

Girl Gone Wild

Masterpiece

Turn Up The Radio

Pretty Good

I may skip them from time to time, but generally I enjoy them. I don't, however, think much about them.

I Fucked Up

Some Girls

Give me all your luvin

I Don't Give A

Not very good

I only listen to them sporadically. I forget they are on MDNA until they show up on my itunes or in the car.

Best Friend

Superstar

Bday song

Bad

I skip them invariably, don't listen to them.

None.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Girl Gone Wild: 4/5

Gang Bang: 4.5/5

I'm Addicted: 4/5

Turn Up The Radio: 3/5

Give Me All Your Luvin': 4/5

Some Girls: 4/5

Superstar: 3/5

I Don't Give A: 3/5

I'm A Sinner: 4/5

Love Spent: 5/5

Masterpiece: 4/5

Falling Free: 3/5

Beautiful Killer: 3/5

I Fucked Up: 5/5

B-Day Song: 0/5

Best Friend: 3.5/5

Some of the songs I didn't really care for at first like Some Girls and I'm A Sinner are kind of growing on me :).

I'm not even going to rate the Party Rock Remix because 1) it's not a real full song, and 2) i hate it haha

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Falling Free 10/10

Love Spent 10/10

I'm Addicted 10/10

Gang Bang 10/10

Some Girls 10/10

Girl Gone Wild 8/10

I'm a Sinner 8/10

Masterpiece 8/10

Turn Up the Radio 7/10

Give Me All Your Luvin' 7/10

I Don't Give A 6/10

Superstar 6/10

Beautiful Killer 8/10

I Fucked Up 7/10

Best Friend 6/10

B'day Song 5/10

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

After a couple of months here are my track ratings for MDNA

Girl Gone Wild: 6.5/10

Gang Bang: 6/10

I'm Addicted: 9.5/10

Turn Up The Radio: 7.5/10

Give Me All Your Luvin': 5/10

Some Girls: 6/10

Superstar: 6.5/10

I Don't Give A: 5.5/10

I'm A Sinner: 6/10

Love Spent: 8/10

Masterpiece: 5.5/10

Falling Free: 6.5/10

Beautiful Killer: 6.5/10

I Fucked Up: 6.5/10

B-Day Song: 6/10

Best Friend: 3/10

Overall : 62%

I think if the lyrics were less cringeworthy it would have gotten nearer the 70% mark.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

After a couple of months here are my track ratings for MDNA

Girl Gone Wild: 6.5/10

Gang Bang: 6/10

I'm Addicted: 9.5/10

Turn Up The Radio: 7.5/10

Give Me All Your Luvin': 5/10

Some Girls: 6/10

Superstar: 6.5/10

I Don't Give A: 5.5/10

I'm A Sinner: 6/10

Love Spent: 8/10

Masterpiece: 5.5/10

Falling Free: 6.5/10

Beautiful Killer: 6.5/10

I Fucked Up: 6.5/10

B-Day Song: 6/10

Best Friend: 3/10

Overall : 62%

I think if the lyrics were less cringeworthy it would have gotten nearer the 70% mark.

wow, it's so sad to be you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

wow, it's so sad to be you.

Is it?, thanks for telling me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Is it?, thanks for telling me.

no problem darling :sassy:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest LOTF

Girl Gone Wild. 9/10. I can't believe this song is getting such bad reviews in here. For me, it's the centerpiece of the whole album. I had understood that this was the sound M was going for with this album. It's dance-able and enjoyable. I love how campy the intro (act of contrition) is.

Gang Bang. 9/10. So different from what we've heard before. I love the music and also how campy the song is towards the end.

I'm Addicted. 9/10. Great song. Very sophisticated IMO.

Turn Up the Radio. 8/10. Lovely and catchy track.

Give me all your luvin. 6/10. I somewhat like the Mickey vibe to it but considering it's Madonna, MIA and Nicki together, the song is very tame. I wish it was more daring.

Some Girls. 8/10. I don't mind the distorted vocals, it's catchy and dance-able.

Superstar. 4/10. Annoying.

I don't give a. 8/10. Loving Nicki's rap.

I'm a Sinner. 9/10. One of the best tracks of the album, loving the lyrics and the music.

Love Spent. 7.5/10. I don't know what's the big fuss about this song. It's good but not that good.

Masterpiece. 8/10. One of her best ballads.

Falling Free. 9/10. Perfect, it reminds me of the Ray of Light demos. Loving her vocals here.

Beautiful Killer. 5/10. Filler. Thank god, it is just a bonus track.

I fucked up. 5/10. Another filler, I don't like her vocals here.

B-day song. 2/10. WTF at this song, I expected better from a Madonna/MIA collaboration. I give it a few points for being some joyful.

Best friend.5/10. Not liking the vocals nor the somewhat urban music.

GMAYL (LMFAO mix). 7/10. This is an enjoyable and dance-able mix.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm Addicted

Love Spent

Falling Free

Some Girls

Gang Bang

I Don't Give A

I'm A Sinner

Turn Up The Radio

Girl Gone Wild

Give Me All Your Luvin

Masterpiece

Beautiful Killer

Superstar

B-Day Song

I Fucked Up

Best Friend

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I feel like I can finally rate the songs.

Songs that I LOVE:

1. Gang Bang: 10/10

2. I'm A Sinner: 10/10

3. I'm Addicted: 9.5/10

4. Beautiful Killer: 9.5/

5. I Don't Give A: 9/10

6. Give Me All Your Luvin': 8.5/10 (I fucking love this song and all of you can SUCK IT)

7. Love Spent: 8.5/10

8. Girl Gone Wild: 7.5/10

9. Turn Up The Radio: 7/10

10. Falling Free: 7/10

11. Some Girls: 6.5/10

12. Superstar: 6.5/10

13. I Fucked Up: 6/10

I don't care for these:

14. B-Day Song: -/10

15. Masterpiece: -/10

16. Best Friend: -/10

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

1. I'm a Sinner

2. Love Spent

3. Masterpiece

4. Falling Free

5. I'm Addicted

6. Some Girls

7. Give me all your Luvin

8. I don't give A

9. Girl Gone Wild

10. Gang Bang

11. Turn up the Radio

12. Superstar

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Girl Gone Wild: 8/10

Gang Bang: 7/10

I'm Addicted: 5/10

Turn Up The Radio: 5/10

Give Me All Your Luvin': 7/10

Some Girls: 5/10

Superstar: 5/10

I Don't Give A: 5/10

I'm A Sinner: 4/10

Love Spent: 10/10

Masterpiece: 8/10

Falling Free: 5/10

Beautiful Killer: 8/10

I Fucked Up: 6/10

B-Day Song: 5/10

Best Friend: 6/10

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hello, I'm Christopher (: This is my first post.

Girl Gone Wild (5/5) – I was not feeling this track at all when I first heard it. It felt unnecessary because Madonna went wild years ago, but after listening to MDNA a handful of times it has become one of my favorites.

Gang Bang (2/5) – I don’t have much to say about this song. It’s extremely boring. It’s the worst song on the album in my opinion.

I’m Addicted (3/5) – This song is a little forgettable. It’s definitely a remedy for the track before it. The MDMA part is pretty good though.

Turn Up the Radio (3/5) – This song screams “make me a single”. It’s catchy and has potential to become a fun summer hit.

Give Me All Your Luvin’ (3/5) – This song is extremely catchy, but yet another that had to grow on me. The lyrics are extremely grade school, but that may or may not be on purpose. It would be better if it weren’t plagued by the gratuitous feature of Nicki Minaj.

Some Girls (3/5) – This is an easy listen but nothing to add to Celebration 2: Greater Greatest Hits.

Superstar (5/5) – I was surprised by how much I like this song. I didn’t pay much attention to it on the first listen, but it caught my eye, well ear while getting airtime on a BRAVO promo. This song is another summer hit in the making.

I Don’t Give A (2/5) – No more Nicki Minaj, please?

I’m a Sinner (3/5) – Simple and fun pop song.

Love Spent (5/5) – Now this song I loved instantly. Everything works here for me. The lyrics are tight, the beats are aplenty, and the banjo, the banjo!

Masterpiece (5/5) – This song is mellow and melancholy. I love it. Every pop album could use a great ballad.

Falling Free (3/5) – This is a pretty song. It sounds to me like the 2012 version of “Mer Girl”.

Needing:

Girl Gone Wild

Superstar

Love Spent

Masterpiece

Wanting:

I’m Addicted

Turn Up the Radio

Give Me All Your Luvin’

Some Girls

I’m a Sinner

Falling Free

Waiting:

Gang Bang

I Don’t Give A

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Girl Gone Wild 7/10 Not a bad song by any means, it just feels kind of limp. I usually play it when I put the album on but I could honestly take it or leave it. For an album and tour opener that was obviously meant to be the general running theme of this era it's pretty weak.

Gang Bang 7/10 I get that this a slow burn build up to the climax. But it feels too repetitive in the build up, and in the climax I feel like she's holding back a little. It's not surprising this is a huge fan favorite - it's not like anything else she's done. But it could be better.

I'm Addicted 10/10 Now we're talking! Perfect song. It builds and climaxes, then pulls back, and builds again. it's a constant push-pull. Her voice is great, production is perfect, I just love it.

Turn Up The Radio 7/10 Not bad, not great. Her voice could be better and the production feels a bit limp. But it's really catchy and anthemic so it works.

Give Me All Your Luvin 9/10 I actually love GMAYL. I love the vocal melody, the retro-ish production, and the placement of the raps. The sound is really crisp and it's just plain fun. Imo this song really works but I know I'm in the minority. Oh well.

Some Girls 10/10 Perfection! Great vocals, nice chunky beat, cool synths. Lots of little details in the background you only pick up on with repeat listens. Probably in the top 3 of the album for me.

Superstar 4/10 Meh. Weakest song on the album proper.

I Don't Give A 8/10 The beat and vocal melodies in the chorus remind me of Sidewalk Talk. She really lays it out here, we get a glimpse of what her life is like post-divorce. Really personal song. Nice and anthemic.

I'm A Sinner 6/10 Feels like an unnecessary retread. I don't dislike IAS but it's not amazing either. It has some great lyrics that are actually rather poetic. It feels like a chore to listen to for some reason.

Love Spent 10/10 :wow: :wow: :wow: Glorious. That's all.

Masterpiece 7/10 Another not bad not great song. It just feels like it's missing something. Looks like the live performance may really turn this good song one into a great one.

Falling Free 10/10 The voice, the lyrics, the music. It's all perfect. Amazing.

Beautiful Killer 6/10 Not bad, but it's kind of bland. I'd swap this out with Superstar on the standard album.

I Fucked Up 1/10 Worst of 'em all. Just blah. Vocals and music sound like they're from two completely different songs. It just doesn't work.

B-day Song 4/10 Not as bad as some say, but not great by any stretch. Goofy and carefree.

Best Friend 4/10 I kinda like it. Cool beat and a heartbreaking message.

Love Spent (Acoustic Version) 10/10 :wow: :wow: :wow: Almost as good as the original version. On some days I actually prefer this one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...