Jump to content
MadonnaNation.com Forums


  • Posts

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by bardo

  1. i think it would have been a cool idea (and made more sense with the various disguises we saw in the promo videos). i also think a surprise drop without any pre-release singles would have been a great idea for this kind of unconventional album. if she's not going to get any airplay or traction with singles, why even bother anymore?
  2. i believe this was post-liz and was done under bb gun, which is an indie PR firm they hired. they had no idea what to do with her. and lede company isn't much better. all they know how to do is one-size-fits-all strategy. they have no understanding of m's legacy or fanbase.
  3. i'd be down for some remixes but i have a feeling it might not happen. maybe due to the subject matter?
  4. will we ever get the remixes on streaming/digital?
  5. doesn't have to be all 50. even just a 15-track album sequenced like a dj set would be a great thank you to the fans. semi-related, i think a madame x remix album would be a great idea. the remixes so far have been very good so why not doing a few more and throw an album together? this is where a proper record label would be useful.
  6. oh i see. if we're going by wiki, "i rise" is considered an official single because it was sent to italian radio. "god control" (and "batuka") aren't listed as a promotional singles because they weren't released prior to the album like "i rise," "dark ballet" and "future" even though they both had videos. i guess we'll see what happens with "god control." i'm curious what remixes would be like.
  7. was "i rise" an "official single"? hard to tell the difference these days, especially with this album.
  8. i think they usually do it when it's closer to #1. hopefully next week?
  9. maybe makes sense for clubs since it's better to have a nonstop beat but still hope some more interesting ones are on the way.
  10. yeah i'm not really sure what the purpose of these remixes are. i'd just as well listen to the album mix.
  11. i'd personally love to see a video, but i don't think it will happen unless it's done on the cheap. maybe a live video? even "god control" with all the press only got a few million views.
  12. in 2002 madonna was coming off a massive renaissance. lol.
  13. translation probably isn't the right word, since mirwais supposedly wrote it in english. but let's use casey's own words then: he claims he "cleaned it up, did some editing, Americanized the language." that means the dude's a copyeditor then and i think $25k and 15% sounds fair. this didn't need to be a social media spectacle. unlike mirwais, m's team isn't ignoring him. he's clearly trying to embarrass and pressure her and no matter what you think of the situation, it's just a bad look.
  14. i'm not really sure why this had to be so public or so messy. it's not like he's taylor swift fighting for her masters. putting aside my disappointment that madonna obviously didn't contribute a whole lot to my favorite part of the song, spooner clearly says that mirwais had a "clear concept, lyric, and melody" - so it seems like he cleaned up mirwais's english, which is more like translating than "co-writing," and was the demo singer. mirwais ended up giving the track to madonna, which is something he's done with his own songs in the past. it might be true that legally he had to get casey's permission in order to do that, but madonna's team was very generous to more than double their initial offer and 15% of the royalties. sorry it's not 1995, casey. record sales are in the toilet and madonna doesn't do well with streaming - so you're going after her touring revenue? if you're in it for the money, maybe work with taylor and not mirwais next time?
  15. benny benassi it listed on all of the new mixes on spotify. aside from the boris remix, i prefer the first batch.
  16. it's a groove. and what she did with the bridge on the radio edit is really pretty.
  17. milking the traffic they got from that review i see.
  18. my guess is that they'll release "god control" mixes first, assuming that's happening. they should just release a madame x remix album for xmas.
  19. who's that girl lauren who was in the studio with her? i think it was someone random like that.
  20. i honestly don't know where they're digging up some of these nobody remixers but i think this is the best remix package in a while. here's my ranking: 1. tracy young (prefer the radio edit because it includes the bridge) 2. benny benassi (i love the "dangerous" part - wish it was repeated more) 3. RNG (catchy late 90s/early aughts sound - reminds me of some of rauhofer's remixes, and i like how the bridge is incorporated) 4. dan de leon & anthony griego (has a 90s/tribal feel - maybe a little repetitive) 5. otto benson (definitely the most "current" sounding but i don't mind it) 6. twisted dee & diego fernandez (generic/forgettable - the only one i really don't like)
  21. i think the main difference is that the radio edit features the bridge, which i think is essential to the song. i guess the other version is better for clubs though.
  22. if you listen to them, you'll hear that there are distinct differences.
  23. well, it seems like they're timing the release to push the song up the dance chart so she hits #1. my only gripe is that "i rise" was released at all and delayed "crave" mixes, which should have been released while the song was doing well on AC radio. dropping all of the videos so quickly has added to the confusion.
  • Create New...